Friday, October 10, 2014

TV Review: Mulaney

So, exactly how bad is the new Fox sitcom, Mulaney? It reminded me of what a bad Saturday Night Live sketch would be if they decided to do a parody of a stereotypical bad sitcom. It wasn't like they tried to make it funny and failed; it was like they tried to make it awful and succeeded.

The show has been compared, favorably and unfavorably, to the classic Seinfeld, and you can’t help but recall the early Seinfelds when every show began with Jerry Seinfeld doing stand-up. John Mulaney begins his show with his stand-up act, the only difference being that jerry Seinfeld is maybe one of the five best stand-up comedians of all time (George Carlin, Lenny Bruce, Bill Cosby, Richard Pryor . . . okay for now) and John Mulaney is not.

It is the sort of sitcom where the main character’s wacky friend bursts into the doctor’s office where the main character is waiting, yells “I’m not crazy!!!!!!” to the assembled crowd, and then squirts massive quantities of hand sanitizer on her hands.  Why is she going to her friend’s doctor’s appointment? Who enters a doctor’s office full of strangers yelling, “I’m not crazy!!!!!!”? Why would anyone remain friends with someone who behaved like that? Then again, why would a man tells his doctor he suffered from “frequent urination” when he wanted anti-anxiety medication because he was nervous about a job interview?

Seinfeld drew laughs from taking real life situations and blowing them up to gigantic proportions. Mulaney bears no relationship to anything remotely resembling the universe the rest of us inhabit. Every character on the show behaves like no one you would ever meet in real life, or on a bad acid trip.


I've said before that it is sometimes difficult to judge a sitcom by its pilot. Mulaney is so cynically constructed to be a carbon copy of other not-very good sitcoms that I can’t imagine it improving. Lucky for me, I don’t have to waste my time finding out.

Friday, October 3, 2014

TV Reviews: Selfie and A to Z

Pilots for sitcoms are hard to evaluate, because they not only have to be funny, but they have to establish the premise, introduce the characters, and leave the door open for more wacky adventures next week. Often, one of two things will happen: either the pilot will be lovingly crafted over years by the writer, creating a brilliant half-hour playlet that subsequent episodes can’t come close to; or the writer has to make a bunch of compromises with corporate suits just to get the pilot made, but then when the suits are too busy to hover over the series, the true quality can emerge.

One hopes the latter will happen with Selfie, a modest new sitcom on ABC’s Tuesday night line-up. The pilot shows signs of corporate meddling. “Hey, can we get a gratuitous shot of Karen Gillian in her underwear? You know what’s funny? People spilling barf on themselves. Can you put that in?”

On other hand, the show is a variation of Pygmalion, which was once turned into a little movie called My Fair Lady. So there is definitely room for growth.  The show also features two extremely likable stars, Karen Gillian (Doctor Who, also Guardians of the Galaxy although you’d never recognize her) and John Cho (the Star Trek movie franchise, the late lamented Go On, Sleepy Hollow). A lot of sitcoms have lasted longer than a season with worse casts than that.

The twist on My Fair Lady is that there Eliza Doolittle’s burden was her poverty; in Selfie, Eliza Dooley’s problem is due to affluence.  Gillian’s Dooley is a top sales person at a pharmaceutical company (I think; I wasn't quite clear on that) who has a bad social media day (see the reference to barf, above) and realizes that she needs fewer Facebook friends and more friends that actually like her. The pilot spent so much time setting that up that they neglected the back story on Cho’s character, Henry Higgs (the names aren’t exactly subtle), a marketing analyst (again, I think) whom Dooley begs to help her connect more with real people.

It’s plain to see what Dooley hopes to get out of the arrangement, but it is less clear why Higgs wants to help her.  Other than the fact that she’s gorgeous, but that doesn't seem to penetrate his consciousness in the pilot, so who knows? Higgs finds everything about her annoying, yet he seems to feel the need to help her because the plot demands it. One can only hope future episodes flesh out this relationship more thoroughly (speaking of flesh, did I mention Gillian was in her underwear in the pilot?).

The producers of How I Met Your Mother did the nearly impossible; after a build-up of eight years, they cast an actress as the titular Mother who was as wonderful, charming, beautiful, and winning as advertised. They then killed her off, but never mind. It is with that background that I approached the new NBC sitcom A to Z, starring the Mother herself, Cristin Miloti.

This pilot strikes me as the first kind I mentioned, so cute and precious that it feels like someone spent a long time getting all these details just so. But once the pilot is over, even though we are promised 25 more episodes (each named after a letter of the alphabet, just like a Sue Grafton novel). The pilot for A to Z is intricately plotted with lots of flair, from flashbacks to voiceovers (for the record, I am in favor of anything that provides work for Katy Sagal), but one doubts the writing staff can keep up that level of intricacy.  How cute is the pilot? The male lead’s name is Andrew and the woman’s is Zelda (A to Z! Get it?).

While the show lovingly spools out the details of the relationship of the central couple, played by Miloti and Ben Feldman (almost unrecognizable from his brilliant turn as Ginsberg on Mad Men), it relies on standard sitcom tropes for the supporting cast, including a stereotypical obnoxious best friend for him, a stereotypical over-sexed best friend for her, and an oafishly obnoxious boss for him. Since she works for what she refers to as a horrible law firm in the pilot, one assumes she’ll have an obnoxious boss in the future.


The pilot is too cutesy to be laugh out loud funny, and when it swings for the fences it whiffs big time. Feldman and Miloti have great chemistry (I suspect Miloti would have chemistry with a spice rack) but people don’t watch sitcoms for chemistry. Sam and Diane had chemistry on Cheers; they were also really funny.

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

The NFL and blackouts (that have nothing to do with concussions)

The United States was a simpler place forty years ago. The United States Postal Service had a monopoly on mail delivery, any questions you had could be answered by looking in an encyclopedia, and the only performance enhancing drugs athletes took were uppers. Oh, and football teams really wanted you to come to the games.

The threat of expansion of cable networks (remember when TBS and WGN were exotic?) led the Federal Communications Commission to promulgate a rule that allowed all major sports in America to prevent the broadcast or dissemination of the descriptions or accounts of a professional sports contest unless that game had been sold out 72 hours in advance. This was actually progress over prior rules, which had blocked the broadcast of local sporting events even if they had been sold out.

However, the FCC just voted 5-0 to issue a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that says that they want to repeal the rule. The fact that this decision will have very little impact on the nature of sport fandom sort of proves just how antiquated the rule is in the first place.

Why the change of heart? The FCC Notice provides a detailed history of the blackout policy, which was a temporary law that expired in 1974 and was then perpetuated as an FCC rule in 1975. You have to remember that when baseball games were first broadcast on radio, some owners felt that if you gave away the games for free on the radio no one would go to see the games any more.  It never occurred to them that the radio broadcasts were free advertising for the games (a book titled Lords of the Realm nicely details the history of baseball owners being complete idiots; it didn't start with George Steinbrenner).  Initially even sold out football games were blacked out, which seems overkill.

But lest we dismiss these concerns too cavalierly, at one time NFL games not being 100% sold out was a more common fact of life. Yes, last year only one game was blacked out, but in 1974, before the current rule was adopted but statute enforced the policy, 59% of NFL games were blackout out on local television. However by 2011 only 16 games would be blacked out, and then only in four cities (Buffalo, Cincinnati, San Diego and Tampa).

In 1975 the FCC found that “[g]ate receipts are the primary source of revenues for some sports clubs,” a fact that is no longer true for the NFL. Testimony before the FCC established that gate receipts now account for a mere 20% of team revenues, while television revenues are three times more important at 60%. The sad fact is that in places like Tampa, they show the NFL Red Zone cable channel on their jumbotron, trying to lure fans to the stadium with the promise of televised highlights.

What is the NFL’s response to this seemingly reasonable acknowledgement of the evolution of NFL marketing? According to NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy, “The NFL is the only sports league that televises every one of its games on free, over-the-air television. The FCC;s decision will not change that commitment for the foreseeable future”  That’s great. However, as I posted a few weeks ago, less than 10% of households still watch a TV set attached to an antenna, so that’s sort of irrelevant (and makes me wonder about the Monday Night game shown on ESPN). Second, the teams in the NFL play only 16 games per season, compared to 82 for basketball and 162 for baseball (to loosely quote great Baltimore Orioles manager Earl Weaver, “This isn't football; we do this every day.”). So the number of football games telecast is still paltry compared to the number of NBA and MLB games. Third, as pointed out in the FCC Notice, football is the only sport with an exclusive contract for network coverage of its games; baseball allows teams to make individual contracts with local broadcasters (that are NOT blacked out; the Commissioner’s office testified that MLB teams broadcast 151 out of 162 games per season).

So the NFL spokesman appears not to know what he’s talking about.  No surprise there.

What the NFL is saying is that it is committed to broadcasting all its games for free, and to do that it needs a rule blacking out the game if it isn't sold out. So, in order to make all games available, some games will have to be unavailable. That logic is similar to that of the US in the Vietnamese war when we said the only way to save a village was to destroy it.


Today, the blackout rule does seem to be a relic, given the NFL emphasis on TV revenues over gate receipts, and if it goes away not many people will notice. However, given how newer stadiums are emphasizing the TV presentation by installing bigger jumbotrons, and that many fans seem to prefer the home theater experience to paying high parking fees to pay large amounts for bad tickets at a stadium with limited replay, cut ins from other games, and (God help us) fantasy updates, maybe in the future the NFL will have increased difficulties selling out games. Instead of denying fans the chance to see the game, the NFL should try and find ways to make the stadium experience better.  Like lowering prices.

Monday, September 29, 2014

TV Review: How to Get Away With Murder


The new Thursday night entry on ABC is called How to Get away With Murder.  It is about an attractive African-American woman who is a top criminal defense attorney who wears red leather outfits while teaching first year criminal law at a prestigious law school and who recruits students to work with her in high profile criminal cases.

This premise is so outrageous it makes Lost look like a Ken Burns documentary.

Where to begin?  No top criminal defense attorney teaches a regular first year class at a major law school.  They are too busy putting in billable hours to take time off to teach first year law.  A top criminal defense attorney may teach a third year seminar, but first year professoring is pretty much a full time obligation (although I did have a civil procedure professor who was on a sabbatical from practice).

Second, what she is teaching is not anything resembling “law.”  For example, one student ingratiates herself to the professor by calling optometrists, pretending to be the secretary of a prosecution witness, and learns that the witness is color-blind.  And what legal theory does that support? All of her stratagems are based on facts, not legal principles, so the kids aren't learning anything about law.

The professor has each member of the class take 60 seconds to offer their best theory for a defense to an actual murder case.  These are first year students who know nothing about law, certainly less than any actual member of the bar, yet she spends a couple of hours (it’s a large class) listening to their uninformed, half-baked ideas.  Ideas that they are given 60 seconds to present, so heaven forbid the explanation be the least bit complicated or require legal research.

The winners of the competition get a highly prestigious position at her law firm. Despite the fact they know nothing about law.  And aren't licensed to practice. And, again, know less than just about any person who actually had finished law school and passed the bar. And they work at her firm while maintaining a full law school work load (she makes it clear in the pilot she expects the students to ditch their other classes while working on her case).

The preposterousness of the premise is matched by the insipidness of the plotting.  One of the eager first year students gets a bright idea late at night and so goes to the professor’s house (which is inexplicably on the campus). He arrives at the dark house, rings the bell, and when no one answers he tries the door and finding it unlock walks in.  Who walks in to a strange house at night when no one answers the door? He walks in on the professor occupied in flagrante delicto with a hunky detective.  I guess they were too distracted to hear the doorbell or the student yelling “Professor Keating! I’m breaking into your house late at night because I have something important to say!”

For years now I’ve said the Lost episode titled “Eggtown” set the record for most boneheaded legal errors in a single TV show, but How to Get Away With Murder’s pilot may break the record; I can’t say for sure as I threw in the towel about 2/3 of the way through.  In Eggtown, a character was being tried in Federal court on California for state crimes committed in Iowa, the defense was allowed to call a witness before the prosecution (because the prosecution’s opening statement, which has zero evidentiary value, was “devastating”), the main witness for the prosecution was allowed to talk with the defendant before the trial, and the sole witness for the defense is someone who met the witness months after the crime took place and who was in love with her.  That’s a load of BS to top, but How to Get Away With Murder topped it in under 40 minutes.  Congratulations.

Heaven knows I know that any realistic show about the law would be as boring a watching paint dry. And yes, I watched Allie MacBeal faithfully as she filed lawsuits against God and sang karaoke instead of putting in billable hours.  But there is a limit to how far outside the lines you can color before you have to conclude that the show is science fiction, taking place in a parallel universe where human concepts of logic do not apply.


I like science fiction, but How to Get Away With Murder was just too far out there for me to buy into. I just hope the show doesn't inspire hordes of impressionable college students into thinking law school looks like a lot of fun.

Sunday, September 28, 2014

Maybe Weird Al isn't that weird after all

I've always been fascinated by the mayfly-like lifespans of pop acts.  One hit wonders are one thing, but if you go back and look at the length even a super group has on the charts, it’s a wonder anyone produces a second hit album.  Okay, there are outliers like The Rolling Stones who will be touring three years after Keith Richards dies, but on the other hand The Beatles lasted (in America) from 1964 to 1970, six years.  ABBA lasted eight years, from 1973 to 1981. Sheryl Crow first hit the top ten in 1994 and last hit the top 20 in 2003, a nine year span.

Okay, I’m cherry picking data; let’s not talk about Elvis, Elton John, or acts that were successful for decades like Sinatra. The fact is that if a pop act can last for more than a decade, they are special. Weird Al Yankovic first hit the top 20 of the US album chart in 1983. His latest album, Mandatory Fun, became his first number 1 album ever in 2014. That’s 31 years of accordion solos and song parodies; given that his gift is impersonating other acts, that demonstrates an amazing capacity for evolving with the popular times.

Weird Al Yankovic is a singular genius, literally. In a profession where imitation is the sincerest form of creativity, no one has EVER tried to copy what Weird Al Yankovic does, at least not on a regular basis. He has a knack for taking the melody of a hit song, finding the perfect way of changing the lyrics that both work with the music and are internally consistent, and afterwards it sounds like the song should have sounded that way to begin with. The rise of YouTube has fostered some imitators, but none operate on the scale Weird Al does.

Some of his early efforts are fairly obvious; it is no great feat of imagination to change “I Love Rock and Roll” to “I Love Rocky Road,” or “Another One Bites the Dust” to “Another One Rides the Bus.” But his creativity grew as he became more successful.  Converting “Gansta’s Paradise” to “Amish Paradise” is a stroke of genius, giving him not only one of his better parodies but also arguably his best videos.

Talking about videos raises another factor of his creative growth. From 1993 to 2003 he took over directing his own music videos, demonstrating additional skill in creating funny visuals to match the humor in his lyrics. His videos also reinforced his attention to detail; the parody of “Smells Like Teen Spirit” used the same actor who played a janitor in the Nirvana video, and the video for “Bedrock Anthem” was filmed on the same desert location that the Red Hot Chili Peppers used for their video.  It seems like Yankovic puts such confines on himself in order to be more creative.

As I mentioned above, another amazing facet of Weird Al’s success is his ability for follow the changes in the music industry.  He started out doing pop songs, but eventually produced parodies of rap songs, grunge songs, and songs whose genres have probably been forgotten.

Mandatory Fun is the first Weird Al album that I’ve heard that I have no idea what the source material is.  I am so divorced from modern music that the only melody I recognize on Mandatory Fun is Pharrell’s ubiquitous “Happy,” transformed into “Tacky.” But being unfamiliar with the songs he’s parodying doesn’t make them less funny.  “Foil” starts off as an ode to an alternative to Tupperware and devolves into warning about the Illuminati. “Word Crimes” is probably the first song in history to mention the Oxford comma and establishes Yankovic’s cred as someone who may act silly but he sincerely wants his fans to know the difference between “doing well” and “doing good.” The album ends with the epic, 8 minute long “Jackson Park Express,” an original song about a love affair that takes place entirely in a guy’s imagination during a bus ride.

I have some problem with the song “First World Problems.” First of all, the phrase “first world” no longer works; it was coined back when the Soviet bloc was the “second world” and non-aligned countries were called the “third world.” With the fall of the Soviet Union the phrase no longer makes sense. Second, the problems Weird Al details (a pixel being out on his laptop, not having small enough bills for vending machines) are not problems all people in first world countries have, they are problems rich people have. It should have been called “One percenter problems.”

I also find “Mission Statement,” a song that strings together meaningless phrases used by business consultants, to be kicking too easy of a target (it is also very easy to convert the phrases into lyrics as most end with a long E sound (synergy, efficiency, functionality)). The song is not a parody of any song in particular but is a general pastiche of Crosby, Stills and Nash’s style, down to sampling Suite: Judy Blue Eyes at one point (in addition to parodies of specific songs and original songs, Weird Al sometimes writes songs that are merely in the style of an artist; for example, Dare to Be Stupid was an homage to Devo).


Weird Al’s future has been the subject of speculation. An interview with a newspaper in Allentown, PA, was largely misinterpreted his announcing his retirement when what he said was a desire to do no more CDs but more digital distribution.  Part of the success of Mandatory Fun comes from his decision to release videos of the songs on the album for free on YouTube.  Leave it to Weird Al to adapt to the digital revolution.

Saturday, September 27, 2014

Belated TV Review: Continuum

I’ll say it once—spoilers ahead.

I’m getting to this very late because for some reason I missed Continuum season 3 and just caught up with the entire season via streaming.  Continuum is an outlier, a television sci-fi show that sometimes has more ideas and better ideas than most literary science fiction.  In an era where much television science fiction is under-thought and over-wrought, Continuum is just about the sole beacon of light.

To recap quickly, the show is about a cop from 2077 named Keira Cameron (Rachel Nichols) who, while attending the execution of a band of terrorists, is caught up in the wake of their time travel device and is thrown, with them, back to . . . 2012 (they were supposed to travel back in time 5 years but missed). The group, calling themselves by the catchy name of Liber8, start plans to win the future by subverting authority in 2012; Cameron manages to insinuate herself with the local (Vancouver) police department, teaming with a hunky detective who has the very Canadian name of Carlos Fonnegra (Victor Webster).

I like Webster’s performance a lot; it is great that he establishes an immediate rapport with Keira, but there is zero sexual tension as her character tells him she is married (to her future husband).  He is a rare actor who can bring the beefcake but acts like he doesn't expect a woman to drop her panties at the sight of him. I also liked the dynamic between Carlos and the police cyber expert Betty (Jennifer Spence); it is immediately clear that she adores him (and is jealous of Keira), but he ignores her not because she isn't gorgeous, but because he is too just too self-effacing and clueless to notice her signals.

The series has always reveled in unclarity about motives; flash-forwards to the year 2077 reveal that Liber8 are pretty much psychotic murderers who are never the less fighting for freedom, while Keira is a descent, moral human being who defends a fascist corporate state. She spends much of the first season mooning over her son, wanting desperately to get back to him. But, realizing that Liber8 can prevent her world from ever existing, stays to fight Liber8 even as she slowly realizes that despite the high body count, they have a point.

She is helped by a teenager named Alec Sadler (Erik Knudson), who (in the future) invented all the technical gizmos that came back with her from 2077.  The younger version of Alec is able to communicate with Keira’s cerebral implant, view through her eyes, and monitor her uniform which, among other things, can make her invisible.

If it sounds a little confusing, it’s because Continnum has never shied away from some of the more troubling literary aspects of time travel. Early on, the mother of a character is killed before he is born, and he fails to fade away like Marty McFly.  At the end of season 2, Alec travels back in time a week to rescue his girlfriend, followed by Keira; the fact that there are now two of both of them propels much of the action in season 3.

The series grew more assured and daring in season 3.  One episode was set almost entirely in 2077; new characters were introduced as sort of “time cops” whose morality and aims were hard to suss out; a regular character was suddenly killed; and while Cameron’s police superior (Brian Markinson) embraced greater corporate control of the police department, her partner Carlos became increasingly uncomfortable with corporations treating the police as their personal security team.

One of the more frightening aspects of Continuum is how easy it is to project the current state of corporations into a dystopian future where there are no civil liberties and all decisions are made by a “corporate congress.” With US Supreme Court decisions giving corporations the right to spend unlimited amounts of money in the political process and impose the corporation’s “religious beliefs” on their employees, such a corporate controlled future seems a lot closer than 2077.

Towards the end of season 3, all of the characters begin to realize that there is no way to win “the” future because there is no “one” future, but a plethora of futures. Keira accepts that she can never return to her son, who no longer exists in the time line created by her time travel, just as Liber8 members realize that they may free one time line, but that means leaving their time line enslaved. This causes some major shifting of loyalties that none the less feels organic.


Season 3 ended with a doozy of a cliffhanger; here’s hoping that the producers of Continuum get a season 4 to prove that they weren’t just making it up as they went along.

Friday, September 26, 2014

In defense of Ben Affleck


Success in the entertainment world is such a fragile thing.  Talent isn’t enough.  Looks aren’t enough. Luck isn't enough.  Talent, looks and luck doesn’t cut it.  Sometimes someone succeeds and someone else doesn't for reasons that can only be described as ephemeral.

In 1997 two charismatic young actors won Oscars for Best Original Screenplay.  Forget the persistent rumors that William Goldman actually wrote the script, the fact is that Matt Damon and Ben Affleck were on top of the world.  Where things went from there is two stories.

Damon was cast in The Bourne Identity and became the most famous spy in filmdom since Sean Connery was cast as James Bond.  He worked with Steven Soderburgh in the Ocean’s Eleven films. His career even survived The Brothers Grimm, no mean feat.  Success after success, with only a few bumps.

Ben Affleck became a punchline. He battled a killer asteroid in Armageddon.  He single-handedly nearly defeated the Japanese in Pearl Harbor.  The duo that was “Bennifer” begat Gigli, one of the ten or so worst films ever (although my money is still on Zardoz for all time worst).  He married another Jennifer, Garner not Lopez, and made Jersey Girl and Saving Christmas. 

I want to give a full throated defense of Ben Affleck, but I find it hard because frankly I've never understood all the hate.  I liked Daredevil, despite its 42 Metacritic rating (I will not defend the horrible sequel, Elektra; that’s all on Mrs. Affleck).  I liked Paycheck, the John Woo directed flop that Affleck starred in with another of my favorite actors, Aaron Eckart, that got a similar Metacritic score of 43.  He gave a solid supporting performance in the Oscar winning Shakespeare in Love, and did a great job re-teaming with Damon in Dogma. For that matter he was the best actor in a number of Kevin Smith vehicles, most notably Chasing Amy.

But weep not for Mr. Affleck.  For one thing, did I mention he is married to Jennifer Garner, a beautiful and talented actress (who was robbed by not winning a Best Actress Emmy for Alias)?  Professionally things started looking up for him in 2006 when he co-starred in Hollywoodland, where he played tragic TV star George Reeves.  He was nominated for a Golden Globe and his failure to get an Oscar nomination was considered a major snub.

He then started an impressive directing career with 2007’s Gone Baby Gone and 2010’s The Town.  That of course was followed by 2012’s Argo, winner of the Oscar for Best Picture despite the fact that its director, one Mr. Affleck, failed to get nominated for Best Director. This snub was completely unwarranted, as Argo was a period film with exquisite attention to detail and done with nearly unnoticeable technical craftsmanship. The only knock on Argo was that Ben Affleck was wildly miscast as protagonist Tony Mendez, and Affleck gives one of his most subdued performances.

Ben Affleck is now receiving the best reviews of his acting career for Gone Girl, the David Fincher directed film about a man whose wife disappears and he becomes the leading suspect in the media.  Fincher, best known for the technical brilliance and the visual look of his films, has always gotten exceptional performances from his actors (Morgan Freeman and Brad Pitt in Seven, Jodie Foster in Panic Room, Edward Norton and Brad Pitt in Fight Club, Pitt again in Benjamin Button).  It should hardly be surprising that an actor with Affleck’s background should flourish under his direction; maybe Affleck will finally get that Oscar nomination for acting.  Of course he’ll still be trailing Damon who has two Oscar nominations for acting.


Of course Ben Affleck’s next role is taking over the cowl of the Caped Crusader, a role that seriously damaged the careers of Michael Keaton, Val Kilmer and even George Clooney.  I think he’ll be okay as long as his Bat-costume doesn't have nipples.