Thursday, September 25, 2014

Ten years later and we're still Lost

It is common for people to decry network television as being a vast wasteland, a medium that serves up nothing but bland pablum.  And they’d be right—mostly. But networks have to produce three hours of programming nightly, 15 hours a week, 780 hours a year, plus all the non-prime time programming.  Any beast that voracious demands to be fed, and oatmeal isn’t always available. 

Every so often the networks produce something completely original; networks produced TV fare such as Arrested Development, Pushing Daisies, and Quantum Leap.  Sometimes these shows are short lived, filed in the “brilliant but cancelled” category. Occasionally they last longer; Doctor Who has survived in some form for over fifty years now.

The last great innovative network TV show debuted ten years ago this week.  It was called Lost, which also describes how its audience felt over most of the next six years.  For six years water coolers in America were the scene of people discussing smoke monsters, The Others, fate, Benjamin Linus, the Black Rock, and a boy named Waaaaaaaaaaalt. It featured a group of castaways led by a doctor with a compulsion to fix things, a paraplegic named after a philosopher who was their best hunter, a bickering couple who were deeply in love, and the most sympathetic character happened to be a former torturer who had worked for Saddam Hussein.

Lost’s unique combination of character-driven story lines, over the top fantasy elements, kaleidoscopic cast mutations and perpetual cliffhangers spawn dozens of imitators, all of who failed miserably. Lost remains a singular accomplishment. Like the movie Citizen Kane, it is undeniably brilliant, yet we can learn nothing of why it is brilliant. It is more than the sum of its disparate parts.

Most people associate Lost with the more fantastical elements, the smoke monster, time travel, and such nonsense.  My mother, who described anything resembling fantasy as “silly” stuck with Lost even during season 5, which should be called The Season of Time Travel. Why? Lost gave us a collection of the most interesting, complex characters ever assembled for a single show.  Heck, the totality of programming on CBS doesn’t have as many interesting characters as the first season of Lost.

But they didn't stop at season one; it is astonishing to realize that the motivating force for the last three seasons of Lost was the character of Benjamin Linus, who showed up calling himself “Henry Gale” late in season two.  The last great episode the show produced, season four’s “The Constant,” was a love story about Penny and Desmond, also not original characters.  The show endlessly evolved, reinventing itself with each new season, which is an even better trick than creating an original show in the first place.

Lost had its flaws.  I still don’t believe creators Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof had a plan for the middle section of the show.  The first six episodes of season three are six of the worst episodes ever produced for television (in one, the main plot is John Locke’s quest to rescue Mr. Eko, who was kidnapped by a badly animated polar bear); they were clearly spinning their wheels, and got back on track once an end date of six seasons was determined. The episode Eggtown contains more legal errors than the entire run of LA Law.  After its first season, in which it won the Emmy for Best Drama, it won “only” four more Emmys, two for supporting actor (Terry O’Quinn and Michael Emerson) and two for technical categories, which is a small haul for such an influential show.

Lost unfortunately shares a fate that more recently befell How I Met Your Mother, namely a final episode that was deemed so disappointing that it tarnished all that preceded it. [SPOILER ALERT] They’re all in purgatory?  Sayid ends up with Shannon, not Nadia? The smoke monster is Allison Janney’s son? We knew the end would be weird, but seriously, Allison Janney?

Maybe Lost’s epitaph should be something Jacob uttered in the final episode of season five; “It only ends once; anything that happens before that is just progress.” There was a lot of progress before Lost got to its inevitably unsatisfying conclusion.  Lost came along at the perfect time, when the internet could propel it into the social media stratosphere but before the internet got too spoiler-y.  Probably no series in the future can produce so many surprises, because now everything is spoiled.


But I won’t say networks can’t produce another show like Lost; to paraphrase John Locke, I won’t tell networks what they can’t do.

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

TV Review: Gotham

At this point in time we have to conclude that the origin story of Batman is our culture’s Iliad and Odyssey. The tale has been told, retold, re-imagined, re-booted, and translated into every language on Earth.  So while most of time it is safe to call yet another remake a lack of creativity, in the case of the new TV series Gotham it’s more like another caveman gathering us around a campfire to tell the tale for posterity.

Gotham has been described as “Batman without Batman,” which is both fair and unfair. Fair, if the pilot episode is any indication, because the series is going to endlessly tease us with references to what young Master Bruce Wayne will become someday. Unfair because by now the town known as Gotham City has evolved into an entity in its own right, as vibrant and realistic as New York City or Oz. Why shouldn't we be clued in on its origin story as well?

It main character is a neophyte detective named Jim Gordon, who we know will one day become Commissioner Gordon, the man who turns on the big spotlight with the bat symbol on it.  Ben McKenzie, fresh from Southland, plays Gordon with an intensity that was missing from the Commissioner Gordon on the 1960’s series. The dialog tells us he is a war veteran whose father was a crusading District Attorney.  Either that was a long time ago or he didn't crusade enough, because now Gotham is an utterly corrupt metropolis, with the police department barely feigning any interest in fighting crime.

The corruption is embodied by Gordon’s partner, Harvey Bulloch, played with his usual scruffiness by Donal Logue. Before Bulloch can show is new partner “the ropes” they are stuck with a big case, the murder of Thomas and Martha Kent in an alley, in front of their son Bruce. Instead of seeing it as a career making case, Bulloch is annoyed that it will be so high-profile he won’t be able to sweep it under the rug. Gordon makes a promise to Bryce Wayne that he will find the killer, but the audience knows that things won’t be resolved that neatly.

The series looks great, with Gotham alternating between grim dayscapes and even gloomier night scenes (this city must get maybe one day of sunshine per year). Of course it is filled with colorful characters, like Fish Mooney (Jada Pinkett Smith) as a crime boss, Oswald Cobblepot (Robin Lord Taylor) whose odd gait and bad teeth make people call him a penguin, and Selina Kyle (Cameron Bicondova) who moves around with a certain feline grace.  Nudge nudge, wink wink.

The pilot does an excellent job of setting up the players, making it clear (but not too clear) whose side everyone is on, The acting is first rate (for a show based on a graphic novel), and heaven knows the Batman mythos is deep enough to expand upon.  The challenge will be to bring out the interstices in the Gotham mythology while not violating the story line the world is so very familiar with.


Gotham is off to an excellent start. But then I also thought Arrow got off to an excellent start, and while it is enjoying continued success I grew weary of it halfway through its first season. It is one thing to start off occupying a known space; it is another to find new ways to make it interesting. Gotham benefits from the long exposure it’s had in the public imagination, but that just means it will need to contribute to the mythology and not just feed off it.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

TV Review: Forever

 Forever is an amalgam of several other television shows and movies, which is what passes for creativity in the TV industry. The main character works in New York City law enforcement (as a medical examiner) and is immortal (New Amsterdam); his long life has trained him to be hyper-observant and he can deduce things based on trivial evidence (Elementary, Sherlock, Psych); we see flashbacks of his previous lives in other eras (Highlander); the main character is a physically attractive male non-police officer working with an attractive and unmarried female detective (Castle); the main character’s secret is known by a shadowy figure who apparently stages mass accidents in order to locate people who are immortal (um, spoiler alert, but that’s the plot of M. Night Shamaylan’s film Unbreakable).

The show’s biggest asset is its star, Ioan Gruffud. Probably best known for the inane Fantastic Four movies, Gruffud exudes an easy charm, aided by a crooked grin and a lilting accent (he’s Welsh). He hasn’t had much luck with American TV since his breakout role starring in the British adaptations of the Horatio Hornblower novels, shown in America on A&E; he co-starred with Sarah Michelle Geller in the one-season 2011 series Ringer, and he played a lawyer in the very short-lived (four episodes) 2004 show Century City (which can be accurately described in four words: LA Law in 2030).

But Gruffud’s charm is actually part of the problem. His attitude is light and breezy, but at the same time he talks about immortality being his curse.  It’s nice that he is multi-dimensional, but the disparity in tone is occasionally jarring. I know that the “morbid medical examiner” is a stereotype of mystery television, and that breaking clichés is good, but an ME who is happy-go-lucky is hard to accept.

The pilot episode established a few other tidbits of information. Gruffud’s character fell in love with an Army nurse in WWII and adopted a baby rescued from a Nazi concentration camp (in a nice reveal, the baby is now played by Judd Hirsch). Hirsch’s character is the only one who knows Gruffud’s secret, except for someone who keeps calling in a whispery voice claiming to also know. Gruffud is suspected of murder by an attractive New York detective (played by Alana de la Garza) who initially thinks he is the creepiest man she ever met (to be fair, his home is filled with death-related tchotchkes), but she eventually comes to appreciate his deductive skills.  She’s a widow whom we meet leaving a one-night stand, so there is the requisite sexual tension.

It is always hard to judge a show by its pilot. Can the producers come up with clever ways to keep using his immortality as a way to solve crimes? Will the characters prove to have interesting back stories? Can they mesh Gruffud’s jaunty insouciance with the downbeat aspects of his “curse?” The pilot has a lot going for it, but it fails to feel fresh or distinctive.  Elementary is doing the “Sherlock Holmes in modern New York” thing, the flashback devise was done to death by Highlander, and MEs solving murders got worn out with Quincy.


There is potential, but it is hard to imagine Forever pulling out of its cliché nosedive and living longer than 13 weeks.

Monday, September 22, 2014

TV Review: Scorpion

Pity CBS.  Feel sorry for them.  The other networks you may laugh at, mock, point fingers at and snicker, but CBS deserves your pity.  Their problem is that they have been so successful for so long, they've forgotten how to succeed.  They get an innovative (for TV) idea, and they can’t help but pound that square peg until it fits awkwardly into a round hole.

They did it last season to a series called intelligence, which had a promising premise and an appealing cast, but it was forced into fitting the procedural mold that made the CSI and NCIS franchises so successful. What was produced was bland and predictable, and didn’t survive for another season.

This season they are doing the same thing to a new series called Scorpion (cool name, never explained). The concept is not earth-shattering but has potential: a team of socially inept super-geniuses are recruited by Homeland Security to solve what on The Middleman were called “exotic problems.” The show has potential, but first it has to escape the network notes emphasizing procedural elements over interesting characters.

The team is overseen by Robert Patrick, who brings his best glower.  Patrick is a solid actor, best known for Terminator 2 but who also did some underappreciated work subbing for David Duchovney on The X-Files.  He should ground Scorpion when the plots start to spin out of control. The team of geniuses consists of a math prodigy, an engineering genius, and master psychologist, and their leader who claims to have an IQ of 190.  Oh, and a waitress.  Can’t forget the waitress.

The plot of the pilot was mercifully free of the standard terrorist threats or super-villains.  Thanks to a computer glitch, the software at every airport in Southern California goes on the fritz, which means every plane in the area will crash in about two hours.  Or 45 minutes.  Or ten minutes.  It’s hard to keep track, because deadlines keep coming and going. The whole thing is contrived, but what television show plot isn’t?  The plan is to find an uncorrupted version of the software, transfer it to a laptop, then e-mail it to the control tower at LAX, which eventually means having to connect a laptop to an airplane’s computer—with a cable, while the plane is flying.

The whole thing is kept moving at a brisk pace by veteran director Justin Lin.  He not only directed the later installments of the Fast and Furious franchise, but he also directed the brilliant paintball episode of Community (he deserved a best director Emmy, but shows like Community never win Emmys).  Lin keeps things moving fast enough that we don’t have too much time to soak in how absurd the situation is.

It’s hard to judge shows based on pilot episodes. The first episode of Scorpion was amusing enough, but I don’t know if the showrunner and writers will be smart enough to keep a show about a bunch of geniuses credible. And I suspect that the Suits at CBS will provide the producers with “notes” that will slowly drain Scorpion of what little innovation it possesses. 


Scorpion has potential, but I doubt that potential will survive CBS’ need to make the show look like all its other shows.  So feel sorry for CBS; they can win for winning,

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Are Commercials Necessary?

Okay, show of hands—how many of you have watched old TV shows from the 1960s on DVD? Did you find it amazing that back in the Stone Age of television broadcasting a 60-minute long shows ran for more than 52 minutes? Now a days hour long dramas on the “broadcast” networks run for at most 42 minutes out of every hour. One of the recurring themes on the commentaries on DVDs of The Simpsons’ early seasons is the lament that the program is now about two or three minutes shorter because of more commercials, making the inclusion of secondary plot threads problematic.

More commercials per hour creates all sorts of problems.  Channel surfing is impossible, or at least highly inefficient, as you now have more than a 25% chance of landing on another channel during a commercial. Committed storytellers like Matthew Weiner of Mad Men demand that their shows run overtime, commercials be damned.  Taut dramatic programs found on commercial free premium networks like Showtime and HBO consistently win Emmies over network shows that have to break every ten minutes to sell toilet paper.

Television consumers have fought back.  Many people DVR (or record; I still own a VCR) programs just to fast forward past the commercials (a tactic I find essential during election season).  According to MarketingCharts in December of 2013, 7 of 10 homes now have a DVR, subscribe to Netflix, or use Video on Demand.  Or, if they are patient, they may wait for programs to come out on DVDs.  It’s like an ever-escalating war; we zip through commercials on a DVR, and the ad people insert more product placement into programs.

I want to raise a question that I haven’t heard asked here in America—are commercials necessary?

After all, commercials were born in an era when “broadcasters” emitted radio waves and had no way to regulate who received them.  So, in exchange for free entertainment, Americans had to endure two or three minutes of informative playlets that told them what coffees were delicious down to the last drop and what cigarettes had full-bodied flavor.

Britain went a different direction, charging each household with a TV set and annual license, which then went to reimburse broadcasters.  That way Benny Hill was never interrupted by commercials.

Things have changed since the early days of network TV here in America.  The percentage of household enjoying television via the airwaves is somewhere between 7% (CEA, July 30, 2013) to 10% (Hollywood Reporter, September 3, 2013) of American households.  At least 90% of American homes pay to watch TV via cable, satellite, or some streaming system like U-verse. 

So, since watching television is no longer free, why are we still watching commercials?

Let’s do some math (all numbers were found on the internet, so they are naturally indisputable).  The Hollywood Reporter estimated that approximately 103 million out of 114 million US households subscribe to cable, satellite, or some streaming service. The ad group eMarketer puts the amount of ad revenue spent on TV in 2013 at $66.4 billion.  If we divvy that up, it comes to $644.66 per household.  If we wanted to eliminate 25% of commercials, that comes to $13.43 a month per subscriber.

However, that revenue number is for broadcast and cable TV ads; I’m just suggesting subsidizing broadcast providers. The total ad revenue for them is $40.1 billion (according to a website called The Verge), which would break down to $8.11 per month per household to eliminate one-quarter of all commercials.

Would you pay less than $9 a month for 25% fewer commercials eating into episodes of Modern Family or The Good Wife?  My cable bill is pretty high, but I’d be tempted.

Maybe a British system with a “license fee” tacked on to everyone’s cable bill isn't the answer.  I don’t know what the answer is, but I do know the current system is unsustainable.  The eMarketer source projects that TV ad revenue as a percentage of all ad revenue is expected to fall from 39.1% in 2012 to 35.7% in 2018.  An April 10, 2014 posting on The Verge noted that for the first time ever, in 2013 media spending on the internet exceeded ad spending on broadcast TV, by $42.8 billion to $40.1 billion (citing the Interactive Advertising Bureau).

Americans don’t want to watch commercials and so rely on DVR and streaming; that makes each ad minute worth less to advertisers, who pay less; broadcasters (and I use that term loosely) need more revenue, so fill each hour with more commercials, which pushes more people to find ways to avoid commercials.  It’s a vicious circle.


At first affiliates paid networks for content; now networks pay affiliates for access to an audience.  The economics of television have changed over time. Maybe they need to change some more.

Wednesday, September 10, 2014

The People vs. Roger Goodell

In my previous post I ended by opining that Roger Goodell should be fired. Let me make the case more clearly.

I am not saying Goodell should be fired for his initial handling of the Ray Rice suspension. A great many people found two games to be too small; I find the debate over how many games Rice should have been suspended similar to that over how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. Two’s not enough? How about four? Eight? Sixteen? What is the price for beating up a woman? The question is absurd, and I can absolve Roger Goodell for making what turned out to be an unpopular decision. He knew the penalty for clipping is fifteen yards, but the penalty for domestic abuse is a bit more amorphous.

Roger Goodell has lost all credibility, and he won’t get it back. Remember during the “bountygate” incident, when much of Goodell’s case against the New Orleans Saints was based on, “I’m the Commissioner; trust me”? He can’t do that again. Every attempt by the Commissioner’s office to be less than 100% transparent, to try and sweep some embarrassment to the NFL under the rug will now be pounced upon by a pack of reporters looking for another “second video tape” gotcha moment.

Roger Goodell is a small boy standing before his parents, being asked what he did wrong and having no idea.  He is desperately searching for the right thing to say, because he has no idea what is right.  "Mommy, I think Ray Rice should be suspended for two games.”  Mommy glares.  “I mean six games!” More glares.  “I mean, he should be suspended forever and ever!”  If Roger Goodell had a moral center, he would have made a decision and then stuck with it.  Instead, he changes his mind, desperately seeking approval.

Here’s the thing about spin; it only works if you can’t tell its spin. Every statement coming out of the Commissioner’s office now is carefully worded, overtly trying to sound definitive while allowing for wiggle room. It doesn’t help his credibility that he keeps saying things like “we got it wrong.” If I was an owner I’d ask, “What do you mean we, Kemo Sabe?”  That wasn’t a racially offensive joke, right?

Goodell insists he had all the facts before him when he made his decision to suspend Rice for two games. But now he says he had no idea what happened inside the elevator. So, why did he make a decision to suspend Rice for two games without finding that tiny detail out? What did Rice say? What did his finacee say? Did he interview them separately and compare their stories? Did he release Rice’s statement, or make Rice repeat it for reporters to establish a record?  All Rice was required to say for reporters was that he “didn’t want to talk about the past.” How’d that line work out for Mark McGuire?

Goodell says he didn’t know about the second tape. Has he ever BEEN to a casino? There are cameras in the men’s room; of course there was one inside the elevator. If the tape was impossible to get, how did TMZ acquire it? Even if he couldn’t get the tape, what did he think was on it? Rice’s fiancée slipping on a banana peel like in a Keystone Kops movie? He had footage of Rice carrying her limp body out of the elevator and tossing her on the floor like a pile of dirty laundry; he had to know something bad happened, and at that point he should have assumed the worst and allowed Rice the chance to produce the tape to exonerate himself.

Goodell initially suspended Rice for two games for domestic abuse. He then announced a new policy of six game suspensions for first offenders. After the second tape came out, he then suspended Rice for life for a first offense.  Does this sound like the sober, deliberate decision-making of a man paid $44 million a year?
Goodell has either lied or misrepresented himself.  He either knew about the second tape, or he should have known about it.  He either knew what happened in the elevator, or he should have known. He either made the initial decision about Rice without having all the evidence, or he had the evidence and thought a two game suspension was adequate even though he later said a lifetime ban was appropriate.

Do I think Roger Goodell will be fired? Let me ask a question: how many owners are women? Roger Goodell is the NFL Sherriff, but only when it comes to players.  Players like Josh Gordon are suspended an entire year for a drug test so slight that it would have passed if the samples had been tested in the opposite order. Owners like Jim Irsay commit a DUI, yet he is “punished” by being told he has to watch six football games in their mansion instead of the stadium (okay, the billionaire was fined $500,000 too; is that tax deductible in Indiana?). No draft picks lost, no suspension during draft day. Irsay will have Goodell's back, no matter what.

Much to my surprise, 64% of people responding to an ESPN poll agree that Goodell should be fired. Lest you accuse them of liberal bias, ESPN polls also show that an even larger percentage think the Washington team name is okay.

If it happens, I’ll be shocked. But someone making $44 million should be held to a higher standard than Roger Goodell has displayed in handling the Ray Rice case. He has significantly damaged the league’s credibility, and that will interfere with his ability to execute his duties in the future. Reporters will question his every decision, the player’s union will challenge his assertions in negotiations, his ability to enforce the code will be undermined.


Goodell is the face of the NFL. He should have made the right decision and then stuck with it, not made a rash decision and then vacillated trying to appease public opinion. His remaining Commissioner of the NFL is hurting the shield that he has sacrificed his soul to protect.

Monday, September 8, 2014

Here we go again

A few weeks ago, amidst the tumult if the Ray Rice scandal, I posted a blog about how the narrative of the Ray Rice situation, as well as the Donald Sterling situation, had been driven by the fact that people sometimes have trouble processing too much evidence. Ask someone what the penalty for abusing a dog should be and they’d say a week in jail, or maybe a month; show them a video of a man beating up a puppy and they’d say life without parole would be too lenient.

Guess what? It’s happened again.  And it happened to Roger Goddell, so it couldn’t happen to a nicer guy. When Goodell imposed a two game suspension on Ray Rice, all we had to go on was the video footage of Ray Rice dragging his then-fiancée’s limp, unconscious body out of a hotel elevator. Roger Goodell spoke with Ray Rice, who apparently assured him that it was a slight misunderstanding, and Goodell decided a two game suspension was adequate.

Now the footage of what actually happened inside the elevator has come to light, and Roger Goodell’s immediate reaction is to suspend Ray Rice indefinitely. First of all, let’s go over the reasons why this reaction is incredibly stupid.

First of all, it is a classic example of double jeopardy. Ray Rice was tried for the crime of beating his girlfriend and sentenced to a two game suspension. There were howls of protest that the penalty was inadequate, and Goodell later admitted he had screwed up. But still, Ray Rice was convicted and sentenced, and so now it seems unfair to convict him again for the same act.

Okay, let’s say you are one of those people who think that the Founding Fathers put that “double jeopardy” nonsense in the Constitution to help out trial attorneys (those guys were all lawyers). Roger Goodell initially said that the appropriate policy called for a two game suspension, but he subsequently said it would now be 6 games for a first offense and a lifetime ban for the second. But applying this new policy to Ray Rice is like overturning the outcome of a football game in 2013 because the rules were changed in the off-season. This is another thing the Founding Fathers put in the Constitution, no “ex post facto” laws.

But that’s just another lawyerly trick. Let’s say that Rice can be tried under the new policy. In that case, his indefinite suspension only makes sense if this was a second offense, and this is his first, so he should be suspended only six games. Somehow we must live in a universe where if I don’t see Ray Rice hit his girlfriend, but I know he does, that’s one count; but if I then SEE him hit his girlfriend, that’s a second violation. If the incident happened in public, and multiple people took pictures on their cell phones, would each photo be a separate instance of domestic abuse?

Roger Goodell may try and argue that the reason he gave Ray Rice a light suspension is he hadn’t seen the footage from inside the elevator of Rice landing the blows. That’s nonsense. What did Goodell think happened, Ray Rice kissed her really well and she swooned? When you see footage of a man dragging his girlfriend’s unconscious body out of an elevator, you have to assume the worst. You have to assume he hit her as hard as a man can hit a woman, and then tell Rice to prove something else happened, and with hard evidence not just his wife’s say-so (either she loves a man who beats her senseless, or she thinks being the wife of an NFL star is worth an occasional left hook). So even if Goodell didn’t see what had happened, he should have had it is his mind before passing judgment.

This happens on the day when the other shoe dropped in the Donald Sterling saga; another NBA owner announced he was selling his interest in the Atlanta Hawks because of an allegedly racist e-mail he sent several years ago. This is what Sterling hoped to bring out in a trial—how many owners have made statements that in retrospect could be considered offensive to some of their clientele? If Sterling had used his billions to hire detectives to unearth these facts, half the teams in the NBA would probably change owners.

Maybe you think Ray Rice got what he deserved, especially after seeing the video inside the elevator. Maybe you are glad the paltry two game suspension now teeters on becoming a lifetime ban. Fair enough.
But process matters, people. I remember on my first day of law school my civil procedure professor stressing that the Code of Civil Procedure didn’t promise a just outcome, only a fair one. Donald Sterling was railroaded out of the league, so the league never defined exactly what was unacceptable behavior and what wasn’t. Did the comments by the Hawk’s owner rise to the same level? We’ll never know, so he has to sell his share of the team. What if Marc Cuban makes some provocative yet thoughtful comments on race? That might force a sale of the Mavericks.

At some point in the future there will be another domestic violence instance. When that happens, will Goodell (or a future commissioner) follow the process he set down and suspend the player for 6 games? Or will they use Goodell’s power to make ad hoc judgments and reduce the penalty to four games? Or two? Will the case depend on whether there is film or not? Women who get hit where there is a camera will be protected; all others, you’re on your own.


Roger Goodell’s two game suspension of Ray Rice was completely inadequate and morally repugnant, and the man now making that claim is Roger Goodell.