Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Warehouse 13--adieu

Maybe you remember an old series called Babylon 5.  It was on a long time ago, way back in the 1990’s (in case you can’t tell, this is my sarcastic voice).  I liked the show, watched it faithfully, was happy when it survived a cancellation scare, but something always seemed a little off.  Then I was looking through one of my episode guides (I was a fan) and I read the author’s introduction which ended with him saying that Babylon 5 was a great experiment . . . that failed.  It did not change the course of science fiction, or TV production.  For all it achieved (it won two Hugos for best TV production) it never lived up to its potential.

I feel the same now about Warehouse 13.  I was enthused when it debuted, mainly because one of its creators was Jane Espenson, who had written my favorite episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Earshot) and one of my favorite Angel episodes (Guise Will Be Guise).  The premise, a warehouse full of spooky artifacts that had eerie powers, seemed to be a promising premise for an episodic TV show.

It failed.

Not spectacularly.  Not train wreck, Ishtar, or Push Nevada failed.  But it didn’t live up to its potential.  Now that it’s gone I probably won’t give it a second thought.

What went wrong?  Let’s start with casting.  The two leads were portrayed by Eddie McClintock and Joanne Kelly as Pete Lattimer and Myka Bering, two Secret Service Agents recruited to work at the mysterious Warehouse 13 in South Dakota.  First off, McClintock can be a mildly amusing actor, but he was completely unconvincing as an ex-Marine Secret Service agent; way too goofy, too unfocused, too out of control.  Fox Mulder was a more credible Federal agent than McClintock’s character.  Secondly, the two leads had no chemistry.  AT ALL.  Donnie and Marie Osmond generated more sexual chemistry than these two characters. 

To give the show credit, the writers recognized this fact and dealt with it by joking about it.  In one episode Pete and Myka wake up in bed together naked with amnesia, and they immediate conclude that the NEVER would have slept together so there had to be another explanation.  It’s not necessary for your leads to have chemistry, unless of course they are supposed to be another Scully and Mulder.  The lack of sexual zing was exacerbated by having the B-team couple consist of a teenaged girl and a gay guy.

Another thing that went wrong quickly was that the premise proved too fertile.  When literally anything could be an artifact, the writers got lazy throwing stuff out there just because it was convenient.  Sylvia Plath’s typewriter causes ennui?  Really?  This reached absurdity towards the end of the series when Claudia’s sister is given psycho-kinetic temper tantrums by Francis Farmer’s music box.  I didn’t realize that Ms. Farmer could move objects with her mind.

There was also the problem of Genelle Williams as Leena, whose job was . . . I never knew.  She was in 52 of the show’s 64 episodes, but heaven help me I still have NO idea what her function was.  Why the character was put on the show, and why she was allowed to remain so long, is a complete mystery.

The one thing that saved the show from complete despair was the arrival of Alison Scagliotti as Claudia.  She single handedly provided some oomph while the rest of the cast seemed to phone it in (seriously, at some point Joanne Kelly must have told the producers she didn’t feel like getting there early for make-up so she was just going to wear baggy clothes and not do anything with her hair).  Scagliotti also worked well with the character of Douglas Fargo from Eureka, so her energy helped two shows and not just one.


The show wrapped up with a 5th season that lasted just 6 episodes, so it’s not like the SyFy network was besieged with requests to produce more episodes.  They acted like the show’s leaving was an event, but given the Sturm und Drang SF fans produce over the “Greedo shot first” debate, clearly there was not a huge upswelling of support for the show when its cancellation was announced.  Still, 64 episodes is nothing to sneeze at (about 60 more than Push Nevada; does anyone remember that show other than me?).  So adios, Warehouse 13.  I won’t be holding my breath for Warehouse 13—The Movie!

Sunday, May 11, 2014

The Big Bang Theory displays its ignorance

I’m always amazed by how much The Big Bang Theory gets right about the world of theoretical physics. The jargon, the theories, the geek culture.  That’s why I find is equally astonishing that they get some simple things terribly wrong.

Let’s start with the episode (The Contractual Obligation Implementation) where Penny, Amy and Bernadette take a day off from work to go to Disneyland.  Bernadette asks Amy what she told her boss, and Amy goes into an elaborate story of faking food poisoning.  The thing is, both Amy and Bernadette are professional women who have well-paying jobs with benefits (Penny works at the Cheesecake Factory).  Neither would have to “tell their boss” something other than, “I’m taking a personal day tomorrow.”  In the world of biological testing I doubt things are so sensitive that neither could take a day off if she wanted to.
Of course that’s how things work in the real world.  The Big Bang Theory is written by TV writers who don’t get days off or vacation time.  So they assume that if any professional doesn't want to work, the only alternative is calling in sick (all the while making retching sounds). 

Okay, so the writers don’t know about jobs in the real world.  But you’d think they’d know how jobs in the entertainment industry work.  In another episode (The Hesitation Ramification) Penny gets her big break playing a waitress in a scene on NCIS, only to be devastated when the scene is cut from the episode’s broadcast.  Was this a reflection on Penny’s acting skill?  No!  They wouldn't have cut a scene just because the actress cast as the waitress was terrible; the scene was most likely cut for time.  Penny still got paid, she can still put it on her resume, she can still take pride in an accomplishment few actresses achieve: getting paid to act on a high-rated network drama.  So the scene was cut for time; big deal.

Even sillier is Penny’s hesitation to work in a sequel to her previous film, Serial Apist.  In The Indecision Amalgamation she is offered the starring role in Serial Apist 2, but hesitates to take the role.  Why?  Does it require nudity?  Is it an excuse for soft-core porn?  Does she have to sleep with the casting director?  No, she just thinks it is stupid. 

The first rule of Hollywood is that if you are a working actor, you have to work!  Not everyone can star in Sophie’s Choice or The Good Wife; while you are developing your craft you have to pay the bills with whatever comes along.  Dustin Hoffman did a Volkswagen commercial.  Tom Hanks did Bosom Buddies.  Penny seems to equate success in acting with winning an Emmy or an Oscar; just making ends meet is a tremendous achievement.


The producers of The Big Bang Theory should know how the TV industry works, and should give their audience some credit for knowing a little something about it as well.  Penny may be a dumb blonde, but she should be smarter than this, especially after so many year of utter failure.  As Sheldon Cooper might say, in what universe could an intelligent television show about super-smart people be so dumb?

Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Guess Who's Not Coming to the NBA Game?

So, NBA commissioner Adam Silver dropped the hammer on owner Donald Sterling, banning the LA Clippers owner for life and asking the other owners to kick Donald out of their very exclusive club.  As Groucho Marx said in A Night at the Opera, “Let joy be unconfined. Let there be dancing in the streets, drinking in the saloons and necking in the parlor.”

Because I’m that kind of guy, let me offer a defense for Donald Sterling.  He is a reprehensible human being, if indeed he is one, and the comments that were recorded by his mistress (who is about one-fourth his age) were beneath contempt.  Yes, this is my defense.  I’m just warming up.

A couple of points.  Everyone knew Donald Sterling was a racist before these comments came to light.  They knew he was a racist 41 years ago when they approved him buying the Clippers.  They knew he was a racist as he managed the Clippers so badly they were a laughingstock since before his mistress was born.  They knew he was a racist when the US Department of Justice brought charges against him of racial discrimination, charges that he agreed to in a settlement.  They knew he was a racist thanks to innumerable stories from dozens of individuals, including former Clippers GM Elgin Baylor.  So, what’s changed?  If it was okay for him to own the Clippers for 41 years despite being a racist, why is it not okay now?

Secondly, the “crime” he committed was making comments in what he thought was a private phone conversation that was taped by his mistress (who, apparently, has no first name).  The legality of the taping is dubious as in California it is illegal to tape a phone conversation without the knowledge of all participants.  He committed no act with the intension of bringing shame or disrepute to the NBA.  He is probably more upset than anyone that the tape was made public.

Compare that to the actions of Toronto Raptors’ GM Masai Ujiri, who addressed a fan rally in Toronto and purposefully, and with malice aforethought, dropped an F-bomb on the crowd when referring to the Brooklyn Nets.  This is a highly placed employee of an NBA team, dressed in a suit and representing his organization, deliberately and without provocation cursing like a stevedore in front of a crowd that presumably included a few young people not old enough to appreciate his delightful bon mot.  To me, that is far worse than an owner’s secret beliefs being made public against his wishes.  Ujiri was fined a paltry $25,000.

But what is Sterling’s punishment?  A $2.5 million fine? Help me out here, is the fine for having racist beliefs, for having impure thoughts, or is it for allowing his much younger mistress to tape him expressing those thoughts?  Generally people should be held accountable for actions they had control over, and I don’t think releasing the tape was his idea.

Besides, UCLA announced they are returning a $3 million gift Sterling had made to the school.  So, UCLA agreed to pay his fine for him, with change.

His other penalty?  He has to sell the LA Clippers.  The lowly Milwaukee Bucks recently sold for just over half a billion dollars; speculation is that the Clippers, an up-and-coming franchise, might fetch as much as $1 billion.  That’s right—his punishment will be to cash a check for one BEEEELION dollars (as Dr. Evil would say).  That’ll teach him not to believe that all men are brothers.

You want to punish Donald Sterling?  Strap him in a boat on the It’s a Small World ride at Disneyland and make him go through it until his ears bleed.  Instead of making him sell the team, confiscate it and refund his initial purchase price, plus nominal interest.  But to think you are striking a blow for equality that is equivalent to the Emancipation Proclamation by making a known racist pocket $1 billion is ridiculous.

Reports are that Sterling will fight the sale.  He’s done stupid things before, so this would be another.  How did such an idiot acquire so much money in the first place?  Mark Cuban I understand, he’s smart; but Donald Sterling obviously is, um, not.


But at least some good will come out of Sterling’s team of high priced lawyers being able to stimulate the economy by buying yachts and fur coats with all the money he’ll pay them.  Come to think of it, A-Rod’s legal team is available; maybe he should hire them.

Sunday, April 27, 2014

The Supie Awards

Superman is undoubtedly the most enduring superhero in the mythic pantheon of extraordinary individuals.  He has survived World War II, Lex Luthor, kryptonite, and Brandon Routh (barely).  In adapting the role to the silver screen, then the television screen, a variety of liberties have been taken; Lois and Clark was basically a rom-com for the two main characters, while the creators of Smallville promised “no tights, no flights” (how well they kept that promise is open to debate).

Given the many incarnations of Superman over the years (including some I have purposely overlooked like a syndicated TV series called Superboy way back when) it is time to reflect and acknowledge the actors who gave the best performances in the various roles.

role
Adventures of Superman
Superman The Movie (I-IV)
Lois & Clark
Smallville
Superman Returns
Man of Steel
Superman/Clark Kent
George Reeves
Christopher Reeves
Dean Cain
Tom Welling
Brandon Routh
Henry Caville
Lois Lane
Noel Neill
Margot Kidder
Teri Hatcher
Erica Durance
Kate Bosworth
Amy Adams
Jimmy Olsen
Jack Larson
Marc McClure
Michael Landes/Justin Whelin
Alan Ashmore
Sam Huntington

Perry White
John Hamilton
Jackie Cooper
Lane Smith
Michael McKean
Frank Langella
Laurence Fishburne
Lana Lang

Annette O’Toole
Emily Proctor
Kristen Kreuk


Lex Luthor

Gene Hackman
John Shea
Michael Rosenbaum
Kevin Spacey

Ma Kent

Phyllis Thaxter
K Callen
Annette O’Toole
Eva Marie Saint
Diane Lane
Pa Kent

Glenn Ford
Eddie Jones
John Schneider

Kevin Costner


Best Superman: Christopher Reeves
The catch phrase of the film was, “You will believe a man can fly.”  The main reason why that was true was not the special effects, but Reeves’ performance; he acted like he could fly.  He played Superman as an accessible ideal; powerful, caring, self-effacing, sincere but not humorless.  An unknown actor at the time, he immediately became Superman.  He returned to the franchise on Smallville, providing a nice coda to his work.

Best Clark Kent:  Dean Cain
Cain did something remarkable—he made Clark Kent more interesting than Superman.  While Christopher Reeves played up the “bumbling” Clark Kent persona, with over-large glasses and a goofy grin, Cain simply played him as a nice guy who was more than worthy of Lois even without super powers.  He reminded us that, as he put it, “Superman is what I can do; Clark Kent is who I am.”

Best Lois Lane:  Teri Hatcher
Easiest call of all.  Hatcher was perfect; she played Lois as gorgeous, intelligent, fearless to the point of reckless, and just messed up enough so it was credible that she didn't have a steady boyfriend when Clark showed up.  Hatcher subsequently got an Emmy nomination for Desperate Housewives but this role transformed her image from a buxom bimbo to something more (although it is easy to forget that one of the first internet sensations was a photo of Hatcher apparently wearing nothing but Superman’s cape).

Best Jimmy Olsen:  Jack Larson
A thankless role, Larson established the “gosh Mr. White, I’ll never be as good a reporter as Clark and Lois” personality.  He later revived the role on Lois and Clark (when Jimmy was exposed to something causing rapid aging) and had a cameo in Superman Returns.

Best Perry White:  Lane Smith
While John Hamilton made the phrase “Great Caesar’s Ghost!” legendary, Smith updated and supplanted it with his, “Great shades of Elvis!”  Smith was more caring, less blustery than the other Perry Whites, one who cared about Lois and Clark and didn't just yell at them to get their copy in.  He’s been portrayed by fine actors in the movies, but the role has been made smaller.

Best Lex Luthor:  Michael Rosenbaum
Luthor has been played by two Oscar winners (Gene Hackman and Kevin Spacey) and was given a star turn by John Shea, but I am picking Rosenbaum.  He had the advantage of playing young Lex Luthor, and so played the tug-of-war within him as he tries to do good but ends up making decisions with bad consequences.  Lex Luthor as Clark’s friend gave Rosenbaum more chance for nuance than the other actors in the role had.

Best Ma Kent:  Annette O’Toole
I pick O’Toole over K Callen mostly because she also played Lana Lang in Superman III.  Callen redefined the role, making her an avant-garde artist in addition to Clark’s mom, but O’Toole was the model of motherly support (until she was written out of the series by being elected Senator).

Best Pa Kent: Glenn Ford
Eddie Jones and John Schneider were both excellent, but Glenn Ford is the essence of fatherly wisdom when he tells his teenaged son, “You were sent here for a reason, and it wasn't to score touchdowns.”  Ford imbues his brief role with such humanity that his death is painful, even after only a limited amount of screen time.


Finally, a special award to Allison Mack in Smallville for Best Non-canonical character.  She was the heart and soul of that show; I've always liked the fact that in the episode featuring the nascent Justice League she functioned as Watchtower despite the fact that she had no super powers, she was just Chloe Sullivan.  Why young Clark Kent preferred Lana Lang over Chloe is a mystery to me; Chloe was smarter, funnier, more into Clark, and frankly she had bigger boobs.  What more could a budding Superboy want?

Thursday, April 17, 2014

When Exclamation Points Attack!!

Historical epochs often generate the seeds of their own undoing.  Something becomes dominant, and then everyone being dominated focuses all their energy on upsetting the prevailing order until it happens and a new dominator is anointed.  For example, the 1950’s was an era of offense for baseball, with the Yankee sluggers achieving such domination that a musical was written about how other teams felt about the “Damn Yankees.”  In the 1960’s the Yankees faded into obscurity, and baseball embraced players like Sandy Koufax and Bob Gibson and pitchers ruled the roost.

A similar changing of the guard occurred in, well, musicals.  The 1950’s were the apex of the Arthur Freed unit at MGM, with musicals like An American in Paris and Gigi winning Best Picture Oscars, not to mention Singin’ in the Rain, now considered the greatest musical ever made.  But then came the 1960’s and the big budget film musical almost became extinct.  What happened?

An answer to this question is currently being offered in a new book by Matthew Kennedy called Roadshow!  I should clarify that the exclamation point at the end of that sentence is in the book’s title; one of the nutty trends that happened in the 1960’s is that producers tried to convince filmgoers that a movie was important or historic by adding exclamation points to the title.  Thus there is not only Hello Dolly! but also lesser efforts like Star!, Tora! Tora! Tora!, and I Do! I Do!  I tell myself that the exclamation point in Help! is meant to be ironic.

Producers of film musicals fell under two other psychopathologies in the 1960’s.  One was a nearly-religious belief that spending money on musicals would increase the gross, no matter what the money was spent on.  If putting antique beadwork on the dresses worn by extras standing ten feet away from the film’s star in a long shot cost $10,000, then that was money well spent.  The goal was always to top the gross of The Sound of Music, a film that spent 33 weeks at the top of the box office (now if a film spends three weeks at #1 it is nothing short of a miracle).  The assumption seemed to be that more input would result in higher grosses, with no one noticing that The Sound of Music was a low budget film.

The second psychopathology in the production of film musicals was the immediate reflex to cast non-singing actors in leading roles in musicals.  The theory seems to have been that if it worked for Rex Harrison in My Fair Lady, then it would work for [fill in the blank].  This is why film audiences were subjected to the musical croonings of Walter Matthau (Hello Dolly!), Richard Harris (Camelot!), Clint Eastwood and Lee Marvin (Paint Your Wagon!) and Peter O’Toole (Goodbye, Mr. Chips, one of the few musicals discussed in the book that looks good in retrospect).  Almost every time a musical was greenlit, the names of Gregory Peck and Richard Burton were run up a flagpole.

Throughout the decade of the 1960’s studios kept pumping money into bad concepts until the studios collapsed like lumbering dinosaurs.  The amazing thing is not that the musicals that were produced were bad; it is that they are almost entirely forgotten.  In reading the book I had to concede that I could not recall big budget musicals like The Happiest Millionaire (Disney’s follow up to Mary Poppins), Star! or Half a Sixpence.  Surprisingly, even though these films are obscure, they are available ion DVD on Netflix.
It is hard to say what was the last gasp of the big budget studio musical: Oliver!, the last musical until Chicago to win a Best Picture Oscar (a decision that is widely derided today), or Cabaret, which won a Best Director Oscar for Bob Fosse in 1972 and pointed the way to a better, more efficient method of producing musicals that simply couldn’t be replicated by anyone less talented than Fosse (which was everyone).

Roadshow! Does an admirable job of keeping all the balls in the air regarding the numerous fiascos perpetrated by studios in the 1960’s (I haven’t mentioned Doctor Doolittle, the poster child for Bad Film Musical Concepts).  I would have liked a little more delving into the economics of the title format, a method of selling advanced tickets at higher prices to “prestige” movie events.  The roadshow format, with its higher potential grosses, drove the studios to create their brobdignanian productions, but after a few references at the beginning Kennedy focuses mostly on production and spends less time dealing with the marketing aspect of film musicals.


So if you've ever wondered why there were no great movie musicals produced in the 1960’s, here is your answer.  If nothing else, you’ll find a wealth of films to add to your Netflix queue.  And most of them will have exclamation points in the title.

Monday, April 14, 2014

It's Dave Clark's world, we only live in it

Last week PBS televised what has to be one of the most self-indulgent pieces of film-making since Eddie Murphy decided to write, direct and star in a movie (you all remember Harlem Nights, right?).  The Great Performances episode dedicated to the wonderfulness of the Dave Clark Five (DC5 to friends and fans) ran like a Bizarr-o world version of This Is Spinal Tap, set in a universe where the band had actually been competent instead of, um, not.  People like Bruce Springsteen and Elton John extolled the greatness of the Dave Clark Five unreservedly, and said their influence was wide spread (even though they get virtually no air play on the oldies radio station I listen to).  Such fawning over a little remembered band from the mid-60’s was puzzling until all was explained at the end when the credits rolled and it was revealed that the two hour extravaganza was written, produced, directed, and starred Dave Clark.

To paraphrase a line from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, if there is anything out there larger than Dave Clark’s ego I want it hunted down and shot now.

The show made some valid points. DC5 wasn't a one hit wonder, although from Tom Hanks’ spirited speech at their induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame they clearly must have been part of the inspiration for his film That Thing You Do about a fictitious one hit wonder band.  They are in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, despite having a limited shelf life in the United States (one thing I loved about the show was the way they cited chart action in the UK and tried to make it sound like they were talking about the American charts), so they must have some credentials.   And their music was quite distinctive.

So, were fans in the mid-60’s crazy to be so nuts over the Dave Clark Five, or are we ignorant for not equating them with the Beatles, as was done at the time?  The truth lies somewhere in the middle, I suppose.  They weren’t a one hit wonder, but their US career consisted of less than 10 trips to the Top 40, so putting them in the same class as The Beatles and the Rolling Stones is revisionist history.  They did have an infectious beat, a unique sound due to their combination of guitar, organ and sax, and a dedicated fan base at the time.

But the truth is that you really couldn't even call them the best of the British Beatles wanna-bes, a distinction reserved probably for Herman’s Hermits.  Their biggest US hit, Over and Over, is a typical piece of mid-60’s two-minute magic that is not really remembered today (except it plays on an endless loop in Hell for classical musicians who were also EVIL).

The most amazing thing about the show was the revelation that Dave Clark was an actor who starred in a movie.  Not only does he lack charisma, he is a charisma vampire, sucking charisma away from people who are interesting.  He is so wooden and stiff on screen that the idea of him going to acting school is one of the funniest things I've seen on PBS in a long time.  When archival footage shows him being asked how it feel for the DC5’s first hit to knock the Beatles out of the #1 spot on the charts (again, in the UK, not America) he pauses three seconds, smiles stiffly and says, “Glad all over,” which of course was the song’s title. Any comparison to Clark and the natural screen ebullience of the Fab Four is absurd.


Don’t get me wrong, I like the Dave Clark Five despite their current lack of air play (the show made a note that Clark wisely owned all of the band’s masters; is this why they don’t get airplay, because he’s “protecting their brand” by not licensing air play?).  But for PBS to waste two hours that could have been better spent watching dying polar bears or Rick Steves visiting a Norwegian brothel, well they’ll have to give me a lot of tote bags to make it up to me.

Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Why Baseball Is Doomed


Baseball, unlike other major American sports like football and basketball, revels in its history.  As well it should, as it has survived for around 150 years with very little change.  A basketball game from the 1950’s would be impossible to watch today, with all the two-handed set shots, no dunks, and no one over 6’2”.  Football from that era would be 3 yards and a cloud of dust; no Peyton Manning or Drew Brees to make running backs irrelevant.  But a baseball game from the 1920’s would look pretty much like today, except no closers, no bulked up infielders, and, well, no Negros.

Baseball has survived a lot; decades of institutionalized racism, the rise of player unionization (which every person in management said would destroy the game, which is pretty much the NCAA’s line right now on college players), and the pharmacopeia revolution.  But there may be something baseball can’t survive, something that will slowly destroy an essential piece of the fabric of baseball’s universe.  I am talking about instant replay.

When instant replay was trotted out in pre-season and in Australia, it was heralded as a big success.  Plays could be reviewed in under two minutes!  The game would not be delayed, and the calls would be right!  Who could argue with that?

The truth about instant replay is rearing its ugly head.  One replay took over 5 minutes to review, because the crack team in New York in charge of reviewing plays was busy reviewing another play when the second challenge was made.  Gee, that never happened in pre-season; maybe because all the teams weren’t playing at the same time.  However long the review takes is irrelevant, as we now have to put up with managers delaying the game until the team reviews the play before deciding whether to challenge or not.  And if the manager makes a challenge and is wrong, then there is no chance of reviewing a later decision that is more obviously wrong.  When this happened, the cry of many at ESPN was to demand replay on every play.

When baseball was played 100 years ago, when a right handed batter hit a ground ball into the hole and the shortstop backhanded the ball, planted his feet and fired to first base, it was a bang-bang play.  It still is today.  Baseball is a game of dozens, maybe hundreds of close plays.  Was the ball down the line fair or foul, did the fielder catch the ball before he dropped it or not, was the tag applied before or after the runner reached the base?  One game was delayed when the catcher asked what the count was and the umps had to check instant replay. 

Baseball managed all these close plays because fans believed that umps were right 99% of the time, and those few errors would even out over a long season.  Baseball wasn't like football or basketball, where subjective refereeing was accepted.  Kobe Bryant gets foul calls lesser players don’t.  The Heat get foul calls the Sacramento Kings don’t.  The refs “swallow the whistle” during the last 30 seconds of a close game because the players should determine the outcome, not the refs (so if a defensive player hits someone on the other team with a crowbar, hey let’s not stop the game for THAT).

Baseball umps were seen as nearly perfect arbitration machines as have ever existed.  It is the only way anyone could have faith in the system over the course of 162 games.  They navigated the dozens of close plays that happened in every games throughout the season, and once the call was made the game could proceed, except on those occasions when some deranged managers decides to entertain the crowd by acting like a lunatic.

But that’s all gone now.  We don’t rely on the utter infallibility of umpires any more.  Almost anything other than ball and strike calls can be challenged.  The play can be reviewed, dissected, analyzed, and the “right” call can be made.  But if the goal is to get every call right, how long will games last?  Right now we limit the number of challenges, but if the important thing is to get every call right, why should there be a limit?  Let’s review every ball down the line, every tag, every catch.  Why have umps?  We can just let the crew in New York ump every game.

ESPN just reported that someone has suggested “speeding up” games by stopping after seven innings.  This can be shrugged off now, but that will become an imperative once unlimited replays are in effect.  Seven inning games?  Why have starters?  Just have three closers pitch two innings each and a fourth to mop up. 
The whole idea behind a 162 game season is that all the close plays that were called wrong would even out in the end.  But that’s not good enough for us these days.  No, we have the technology; we can make baseball slower, more tedious, more correct.  Wake me when we get to 5 hour games.

Baseball functioned when we blithely assumed the umps were competent and honest.  The whole thing about yelling at umps for being blind only worked as a trope because we knew it wasn’t true.  But thanks to slo-mo instant replay, we aren't so sure anymore.  We've been given the gift/curse of knowledge, and now we demand every close play be reviewed by a higher authority at MLB HQ in New York.  Once the door has been opened, once we've been given the knowledge of how to make fire or build nuclear weapons, the genie can’t be put back into the bottle. 


Baseball has survived a lot, but can it survive instant replay?  I guess the Mona Lisa has survived several centuries of art critics.  But I, for one, am worried.