Monday, March 17, 2014

A Modest March Madness Proposal

Every year at this time I go nuts.  It’s March Madness, almost literally.  I’m not talking about seedings, snubs, or 2/15 upset possibilities.  I’m talking about simple geography.

Presumably the NCAA, the National Collegiate Athletic Association, must be populated by individuals who, you know, went to college.  And presumably a few of those people didn’t go on an athletic scholarship, and therefore actually learned something.  Yet every March the complete ignorance the NCAA selection committee has of United State geography is revealed to be staggering.

Who is in the “West” bracket?  The University of Louisiana at Lafayette.  Because when I think of the western United States, I immediately picture bayous and gators.  What school isn't in the West?  UCLA, which is in the South region.  Because being 20 miles from the Pacific Ocean doesn't mean you are in the West.  Cal Poly also isn't in the West bracket but in the Midwest, because apparently someone thinks that California is located between Indiana and Iowa.

Colorado and Pittsburgh meet in the first round in the South bracket, because both of those places were in the Confederacy during the Civil War.  Albany is also in the South, but not North Carolina State, which is in the Midwest.  Ohio State is not in the Midwest region, but in the South.  Iowa State is in the East, while Manhattan is in the Midwest (because when you think of Manhattan you think of tall buildings, Broadway, and fields of wheat).  Duke is in the Midwest, Milwaukee in the East and so on ad nauseum.

Look, if the regional brackets don’t mean anything, why give them geographical place names?  If teams from California play in the South bracket, why call it the South?  If a team from New York City is in your bracket, it shouldn't be called the Midwest.  Let’s come up with an alternative.

Here is my proposal: instead of naming the brackets after geographical regions, name them after historical figures from college basketball.  You could still maintain some semblance of regionalism, but make it a little more non-specific.  Then the stupidity of saying Duke is in the Midwest isn't quite as glaring.

My suggestion?  The West bracket could be known as the Wooden bracket.  The Midwest bracket should be renamed the Knight bracket.  The South could be transformed into the Smith bracket (if naming it after Dean Smith is too generic, you could always call it the Rupp bracket).  And lastly, the East could be called the Summitt bracket (okay, Tennessee isn't exactly the East, but there isn't a retired basketball coach with her pedigree from a school in the “East.”


Can we please stop destroying the map of the United States every March?  Let’s honor NCAA basketball history and get rid of the geographical brackets that clearly mean nothing.  Now let me get back to my bracket; I can’t decide if North Dakota State is likely to upset Oklahoma in the West.

Monday, March 10, 2014

Pete Rose is back?


There are some people you just wish would go away.  Most of the Kardashians.  At least half of the GOP Presidential candidates from 2012.  Britney Spears.  I don’t understand it; people with talent have a difficult time hitting it big; Spears has no talent what so ever, yet she manages comeback after comeback until you can barely remember those blessed times when she was gone.

In sports, my nominee for Most Annoying Banquo’s Ghost is back on the cover of Sports Illustrated: Pete Rose.  Nearly a quarter of a century after his case was definitively adjudicated, the debate rages over whether he should be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame.  The reason he is not in the Hall of Fame is because of a piece of paper agreeing to a lifetime ban, and that paper is signed by Pete Rose.  Case closed.

But the apologists continue.  Betting on baseball isn't as bad as using steroids.  There really was no evidence he bet on baseball, and even if he did there is no evidence it influenced the outcome of any games.  He’s the all-time hit leader, and how can the guy with the most base hits NOT be in the Hall of Fame (and what about the guy who hit the most home runs?  What are the odds Barry Bonds will be voted into the Hall once he’s eligible?).

The bottom line is this: Pete Rose agreed to a lifetime ban.  If Pete Rose accepted a lifetime ban, the rest of us should as well.  Gambling has been the cardinal (sorry St. Louis) sin of baseball players since the Black Sox scandal.  Gamblers always lose (do you think those big shiny buildings in Las Vegas were built in order to give money away?) and once losses pile up, the risk of influence exists whether it is exerted or not.  Even if Rose never bet on his team to lose, it still could affect performance.  If Rose bet a lot on his team to win a certain game, he might leave a pitcher in longer than he should, making that pitcher unavailable for later games.  Gambling raises the possibility of influence, whether that influence is perceived or not.

As for the fact that Rose is the “all-time hit king,” the fact is that in the latter part of his career, Rose was the least productive first baseman in baseball.  He was a 40 year old spray hitter with no power, yet his manager kept putting him in the line-up.  His manager’s name?  Pete Rose!  In his final year he hit .219 with no home runs and an OPS of .538, yet she still wrote his own name in at first base 45 times.  In his 1986 Baseball Abstract, Bill James rated Rose the 10th best first baseman in the National League (out of 12) and summed him up with one word--"Who?"  He ended up with 67 more hits than Cobb, but he would have been finished at least three years earlier and with 266 fewer hits if he hadn't been his own manager.  So I don’t put too much weight on him getting to the top of that list.

Still, even discounting that achievement, doesn’t Rose deserve to be in the Hall of Fame?  One of the most prolific hitters of all time, key member of the Big Red Machine, one of the greatest teams ever, Charlie Hustle, ender of Ray Fosse’s career.  What does Pete Rose have to do to get into the Hall of Fame?  The answer is simple.

Die.

Pete Rose agreed to a lifetime ban.  Once his lifetime is over, he’s eligible again.  He’s 73 years old, so he’s on the clock.  While he’s alive, he is ineligible to feel the pride of getting into the Baseball Hall of Fame without a ticket.  When he can no longer derive any enjoyment form his inclusion, then he can get in.

Of course the same logic applies to Shoeless Joe Jackson.  His lifetime ban ended years ago; why no one has picked up the banner and advocated for his inclusion is beyond me.  At this point does he even have any living grandchildren who could derive some pleasure from his induction into the Hall of Fame?


So stop the lobbying to get Pete Rose in the Hall of Fame.  He’s not eligible, and the person responsible for that decision was Pete Rose.  The fact that he now has buyer’s remorse and thinks he should be allowed in just means he’s a liar as well as a gambler.  Let’s get Craig Biggio and Mike Piazza in next year and let the Death Watch on Pete Rose start later.

Sunday, March 9, 2014

From TV Screen to Movie Theaters

Movies and television have usually been enemies, like the Capulets and Monagues, or the Hatfields and McCoys.  Movies were America’s biggest entertainment industry until the 1950s, when television entered people’s homes and offered them entertainment without having to leave their abodes.  Movies countered by providing formats that TV couldn’t replicate, like wider screens and bigger budgets.  But TV’s accessibility couldn’t be beat; people went from seeing a movie nearly every week to going a couple of times a year.

Eventually movies decided that if you can’t beat TV, you could replicate it.  I haven’t identified the first movie based on a television show, but at some point the generation of kids raised on TV became movie studio executives, and suddenly big budget movies based on TV shows became ubiquitous (Car 54 Where Are You?  Seriously?).  That tradition is getting a 21st century twist with the upcoming release of Veronica Mars, a movie made possible in part by fans contributing to Kickstarter.

Filmmakers have taken a variety of approaches when converting a television show into a movie.  Some have appropriated the title of a familiar show then completely ignored the original material.  The greatest offender in this category is also one of the most successful film franchises, the Mission Impossible series.  The show featured a group of individuals working as a team under the direction of mastermind Jim Phelps; the first movie was about a lone agent played by Tom Cruise single-handedly attempting to clear himself of treason, only to discover that the real culprit was [SPOILER!] Jim Phelps.  The movies are entertaining, but bear only a superficial relationship to the concept of the TV show.

Another example of a big budget movie that more or less re-wrote the central premise of the series it was based on was Wild Wild West, which turned Secret Service agent Jim West into an ex-slave played by Will Smith.  The movie played as a comedy, which is odd because the original show was an action-adventure series with comedic overtones [interestingly, two TV movies with the original cast also treated the source material as comedy, replacing villain Miguelito Loveless (who was played by dwarf Michael Dunn) with his “son” played by Paul Williams, who was just short].

An ingenious way to get past the lesser quality television shows being converted into movies is the parody route.  This was used to make The Brady Bunch movie tolerable and considerably improved the recent reboot of 21 Jump Street.  The film parody of Dragnet gave Dan Ackroyd one of the best vehicles in his career.  

Another way is to be faithful to the original, but pump it full of bigger stars and better effects.  This was successfully done with The Untouchables, but the extra money did nothing to improve the quality of Lost in Space.

Rare is the TV-based movie that improves on the source material, beyond merely spending more money.  The Addams Family movies were well-cast (I thought Christina Ricci deserved a supporting actress nomination for the second one) and cleverly written.  The Fugitive condensed the multi-year story of Doctor Richard Kimble into an exciting two hour movie.  The J. J. Abrams reboot of the Star Trek franchise has provided an interesting new take on iconic characters (Spock and Uhuru as a couple makes so much sense).
Then there are the plethora of films based on TV shows that are just bad, the reason for the reboot being creative bankruptcy and not the desire to do an homage.  Why anyone would want to see Car 54 Where Are You on the big screen defies explanation.  Lorne Michael produced one good movie from a Saturday Night Live sketch, The Blues Brothers, but since has created an unending stream of drek like Superstar, It’s Pat and The Ladies Man.

It is uncommon for TV shows to make a literal transition to the big screen; by the time a TV show has come to the end of its run, it usually is creatively exhausted.  The X-Files tried the impossible and made a feature movie in the middle of the series, which was modestly successful (the feature film made after the series had ended was a major snore).  Star Trek successfully transitioned to movies after decades of fans clamoring for a return of the TV series; the transition of The Next Generation to movies was less successful.

Perhaps the most artistically successful movie based on a TV show was Serenity, based on the late lamented Joss Whedon vehicle Firefly.  Whedon did the impossible (which he seems to do on a regular basis), creating a film that was intelligible to those un-initiated to the Firefly series but a fulfilling sequel that rewarded fans of the show.  Financially the film opened at number two at the box office on the last week of September 2005, but was out of the twenty within a month; apparently all the Firefly fans went on opening weekend then didn’t go back.  However the movie was Whedon’s first work as a film director, which helped get him the gig as director of The Avengers.

Now comes Veronica Mars, the brilliant, low-rated series created by Rob Thomas that rocketed Kristen Bell to stardom.  In a survey of the past ten years of TV at Television Without Pity, fans voted the character Veronica Mars as “Best Badass” which is pretty impressive when you consider Bell is 5’1” and weighs about 100 pounds soaking wet.  Season one was a masterpiece, with each self-contained episode working as a tile that together formed an incredible mosaic.  Seasons two and three were less successful (has any show set in high school ever successfully transitioned to college?) but still worth watching.

Can Veronica Mars justify its fan’s faith and be a box office hit?  We’ll know after the weekend of March 24th, when the movie goes into wide release.  As a huge fan of the show, I hope so.  The season 3 DVD contained a mini-episode that Rob Thomas did as a pitch for a fourth season, which fast forwarded Veronica out of college and showed her as a neophyte agent with the FBI, and it was so good that I can’t believe the networked passed on it (wait a minute, network executives doing something stupid?  Of course I can believe it).  Apparently in the new incarnation Veronica has turned her back on law enforcement and the movie portrays her as a New York attorney, but old boyfriend Logan gets her to come home to Neptune when he needs her sleuthing skills.


I will continue to believe that most movies based on TV shows are a bad idea (Bewitched?  Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me?).  But if the Veronica Mars movie is comparable in quality to Serenity, it might be proof that there are exceptions to the rule.

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Oscar Predictions 2014

Predicting the Oscars have always been fascinating because they are a black box: we know what we think are the factors that go in to deciding who wins (is someone overdue, was the movie they were in a hit, do they have a reputation, are they impersonating a famous person . . . oh yeah, was their performance good?) but in the end we know only the winner’s name, but not the reason why any particular member of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences voted for them. 

The prediction game has gotten less interesting in recent years, what with the advent of so many pre-Oscar awards and the emergence of social media.  A true upset is almost impossible under these circumstances.  The person who wins the Oscar will almost invariably have picked up a Guild award, Golden Globe, or some critics’ association award before the Oscars are awarded.

This year promised to be one of the most boring Oscar years on record, with most of the major awards locked in once the nominations were announced.  However, some last minute changes to the landscape have managed to add an air of uncertainty, although by and large there should be few surprises on March 2nd.
Best Picture:  Yeah, I’m starting with the big one first, because it is the most interesting.  Most pre-Oscar awards have been going to 12 Years a Slave, with some going to Gravity.  However, I think there are a couple of things to consider before flipping a coin between those two films.  First, the Academy Best Picture winners that have dealt with race have either been light (Driving Miss Daisy) or positive (the abominable Crash, easily the worst Best Picture winner ever).  A dark (pardon the expression) movie like 12 Years might not be some members’ cup of tea.  Science Fiction films taking place in outer space have never been big vote getters when nominated for Best Picture (2001 wasn't even nominated, Star Wars).  The Academy uses a weighted average system of voting, meaning that it is possible for the Least Common Denominator, the film that annoys the fewest people, to win.  So I am predicting an upset and making my pick American Hustle.

What else does Hustle have going for it?  It picked up the Golden Globe for Best Comedy.  It is the second year in a row that director David O. Russell has directed his cast to nominations in all four acting categories, something that has only happened a total of 15 times and not since Reds in 1981 (plus he directed The Fighter which won two acting Oscars and was nominated for Best Picture).  It is an historical film set in the 1970’s, something else Oscar likes (The King’s Speech over The Social Network).  It is a “comedy,” which is a drawback, but it is not a jokefest Animal House kind of comedy but a satire on the era it is set in.  Russell has directed two recent Oscar winners, Christian Bale for The Fighter and Jennifer Lawrence for Silver Linings Playbook. 

So my pick for Best Picture is American Hustle.  If I am right I am a genius; if not, hey I took a shot.

Best Director: Alfonso Cuaron, Gravity.  One point against 12 Years a Slave winning Best Picture is that Steve McQueen almost certainly won’t win Best Director (although being nominated is an accomplishment for an actor who has been dead since 1980).  Cuaron made an eye-popping special effects film that contains two great performances by Sandra Bullock and George Clooney.  He’s picked up just about every pre-Oscar award including the Golden Globe and BAFTA. 

Best Actor: Matthew McConaughey.  When the nominations were first announced, I thought McConaughey’s lightweight filmography (Failure to Launch, Sahara, Ghosts of Girlfriends Past) might cost him votes among those who couldn’t take him seriously as an actor.  But he has added gravitas to his career with recent work in films like Mud and The Lincoln Lawyer, and he’s just about run the table of the pre-Oscar awards.  I’m pulling for Chiwetel Ejiofor just because he starred in Joss Whedon’s Serenity and I always pull for anyone associated with Joss.  But Oscar LOVES actors who make physical transformations for roles (Phillip Seymour Hoffman for Capote), so McConaughey’s got the nod.  My dark horse is Bruce Dern, a respected older actor who’s been nominated before, but older actors usually win in the Supporting category (Alan Arkin, James Coburn).

Best Actress: Cate Blanchette.  This was a stone lock until the flap over child abuse charges were leveled at Woody Allen.  It might cost Cate some votes, but she’s an Oscar winner for The Aviator and gave the stand-out performance in a weak year for Best Actress candidates.

Supporting Actor and Actress:  Jared Leto and Lupita Nyong’o.  They've almost run the table  (Nyong’o lost the Golden Globe to Jennifer Lawrence, but the Academy’s not going to give her an award two years in a row) and the run won’t stop in Oscar night.

Best Adapted Screenplay: 12 Years a Slave.  It will get votes from those who will vote for it for Best Picture, and from those who DON’T vote for it for Best Picture as a consolation prize.

Best Original Screenplay: American Hustle.  There is a strong correlation between winning best picture and winning best screenplay, since I am picking Hustle to win Best Picture I have to be consistent.  Also, the main rival is Spike Jonze’s Her, which is wonderful but again might put some Oscar voters off with the Sci-Fi aspects.  

Best Original song:  When a rap song wins Best Song, it's time to eliminate the category; when a song whose lyrics are in Hindi wins Best Song, it's time to eliminate the category; when a song called "Man or Muppet" wins Best Song, it is past time to eliminate the category.

Monday, February 24, 2014

In Memoriam: Harold Ramis

In Memoriam: Harold Ramis

There was a lot of talk recently about Mount Rushmore when Lebron James made his choice about which iconic NBA stars he would put on “his” basketball Mount Rushmore (of course he then announced by the end of his career he would knock one of them off).  For whatever reason, any talk about the best of anything always requires choosing four to put on that category’s Mount Rushmore.

If you were to choose the Mount Rushmore of film comedies since 1978 it would not be insane to nominate Animal House, Caddyshack, Ghostbusters and Groundhog Day.  You’d almost have to bump Caddyshack in favor of Airplane!, and you could lobby for something from Woody Allen or the Judd Apatow family, but otherwise that’s a solid group of comedies for enshrinement.  What do they have in common?  Harold Ramis.

Unlike other noted film comedy writer/directors like Woody Allen, Charlie Chaplin or Preston Stuges, Ramis was not a singular comedic voice.  His best work was usually in collaboration with others, and his acting work was always in smaller roles.  But the fact that he had some input on so many classic comedies indicates that his comic instincts were formidable.

Putting out a few quality comedies could be a fluke; Ramis was associated with several comedies that were game-changers.  He was a co-writer on Animal House, a movie that transformed the movie industry by showing that a low-budget comedy could generate a huge box office if it was smart and took chances.  He co-wrote and co-starred in Ghostbusters, a film that proved that a big-budget comedy could generate a huge box office if it was smart and took chances (a lesson lost on Steven Spielberg when he made 1941).  He directed and co-wrote Caddyshack, which proved that one way to success is to just get out of Bill Murray’s way and let him ad lib.

And then there is Groundhog Day, which is Harold Ramis’ “Annie Hall,” the film where he went from making “funny” films and managed to combine laughter with heart.  In contrast to his early work which reveled in anarchy (thanks to stars like John Belushi and Bill Murray), Groundhog Day was a screenplay executed with mathematical precision (almost literally; people have tried to estimate exactly how many times weatherman Phil Connor re-lived the same day over and over and over).  It was a film whose unique structure required precision in plotting, character development and dialogue, and Ramis was more than up to the challenge.  Ignored by the Oscars, Ramis won a BAFTA award for Best Original Screenplay.  It was also the first film where Bill Murray’s acting was taken seriously, possibly contributing to his eventual nomination for Lost in Translation.

Unlike Woody Allen, Ramis did not follow Groundhog Day with a series of equally prestigious films.  In fact, his post-Groundhog Day efforts are a litany of mediocre comedies; the only one that stands out at all is Analyze This, which was one of the first films to successfully make hay out of the comedic acting chops of Robert deNiro.  Bedazzled was a poor idea poorly executed; why on Earth would anyone try to improve upon the Dudley Moore/Peter Cook original, especially with Elizabeth Hurley in the role as the Devil (Roger Ebert pointed out that if the Devil looked like Elizabeth Hurley, why is the poor guy selling his soul asking for another woman)?  Year One attempted to tap into the John Belushi zeitgeist with arguably his closest approximation, Jack Black, but it didn’t work. 


But why focus on the negative?  Animal House.  Caddyshack.  Vacation.  Ghostbusters.  Back to School.  Groundhog Day.  Now THAT’s a resume.

Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Sports and Society

We are at a point in history when a derogatory stereotype can be shattered.  Michael Sam, a defensive football player from Missouri, has publicly come out as being gay.  This presents a tremendous opportunity to thoroughly debunk a long-held, deeply ingrained stereotype, namely that all football players are raw meat eating, psychotic homophobes.

Several NFL player tweeted that they didn't have a problem with an openly gay football player.  Almost every quote mentioned on ESPN expressing doubts about whether an openly gay player would be accepted in the NFL came from nameless executives.  None of them said they wouldn't want a gay player on their teams; they all said that they didn't THINK a gay player would be accepted by athletes.

I’m not saying Michael Sam would be welcomed by every player in every locker room.  Given what Richie Incognito did to toughen up a fellow player who was straight, heaven knows what would happen if Sam was an inhabitant of the Miami Dolphins locker room.  But the coach of the Green Bay Packers said he’d be accepted there, and presumably other teams (not to foster another cliche, but maybe the San Francisco 49ers) would not have a problem with a gay player on the roster.

Maybe football players are more evolved than society gives them credit for.  Maybe young football players have been exposed to more openly gay performers, friends, and relatives than older NFL executives.  Maybe not 100% of football players are testosterone fueled idiots who instinctively hate gays, women and nerds.  Sure, there will be some haters; and maybe the percentage of football players harboring anti-gay feeling is higher than that of the general public.  But maybe that percentage is a lot smaller than people assume.

The most noteworthy thing about the whole Michael Sam story is that he came out to his teammates several months ago, and every single one of them respected his privacy and kept his secret.  This is at a time where teenage kids tweet every stupid thought that passes through their heads (oops, that’s another stereotype).  And yet an entire team of macho football players respected Michael Sam so much that not a single one disclosed his announcement. 

Attitudes about gays is notoriously generational.  Someone once said that all that has to happen for gay marriage to be voted into law in most states is a good flu epidemic that might thin the herd of elderly voters.  Ellen DeGeneres is hosting the Academy Awards next month; coming out didn’t hurt her career.  We’ve come a long way from the 1930’s when Hollywood studios ran brothels on their lots and required unmarried actors to “prove” they weren't gay with prostitutes once a week.

We shall have to see what happens with Michael Sam and the NFL draft, and if he is drafted how his presence is dealt with.  One thing is already obvious; societal attitudes towards gays have tipped so far that those who do have a problem with a gay football player are treading lightly and remaining anonymous.  Maybe they’re the ones who are now in a closet harboring a secret they dare not reveal.

Meanwhile, in college basketball, Oklahoma State’s Marcus Smart was suspended three games for shoving a Texas Tech fan after the fan directed a comment towards Smart as he was getting up after falling into the crowd.  Smart said he thought he heard a racial taunt; evidence seems to indicate that the fan actually called him a “piece of crap.” 

I have two comments on the entire situation.  First, I am not one to condone violence, but if a 54 year old fat white guy says to a young, athletic African-American, “You’re a piece of crap,” shouldn’t he expect a lot more than a shove?  Can you imagine any context when a fat 54 year old white guy could go up to a young, athletic African American man, call him excrement, and violence would NOT ensue?  Either this guy is dumber than a sack of Texas dirt, or he felt that he was protected by Texas Tech and was thus free to hurl insults at the other team.

Second, both Smart and the fan used the same tired excuse in their apologies; both said that the action that they took “wasn't me.”  I am sick of people committing some heinous act, usually on camera so it can’t be denied, and then saying, “That’s not who I am.”  No, that’s EXACTLY who you are.  The Texas Tech fan is someone who loves to sit close to the court and yell insults at the athletes representing the other team (the idea that this is the first time he EVER yelled an insult at a member of the other team defies credibility), and there had been concerns about Smart’s previous incidents of displaying temper.  People, you are what you do.  I just wish someone would be caught punching an opposing player in the back of the head and apologize by saying, “I’m sorry I got caught.”


Sports is a microcosm of society.  Sometimes sports is ahead of the curve (Jackie Robinson) and sometimes it has to be dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st century (instant replay in baseball).  Michael Sam proves we've come a long way; the Marcus Smart incident proves we have a long way to go.

Thursday, February 6, 2014

TV Review: Sherlock

Warning: Here there be spoilers

After two long years the series Sherlock returned to American television with three new episodes, once again proving that the British model of television production is a far cry from its American counterpart.  American networks are reducing their commitment to new shows (Sleepy Hollow is arguably the biggest hit of the season but Fox is only producing 13 episodes instead of the usual 22), but for the BBC to call three episodes a season is pushing things well beyond where US networks are willing to go.

The third season of Sherlock is, in my view, the weakest of the three seasons taken as a whole.  It did not produce an episode as weak as season one’s The Blind Banker or season two’s The Hounds of Baskerville, but neither did it approach the giddy heights of The Great Game or A Scandal in Belgravia.  It never really produced a reasonable explanation for Sherlock not being dead after the events of The Reichenbach Fall, although it did have a great deal of fun in refusing to play fair and say what happened.  And the season finale dealt with a villain so underwhelming that the possible return of Moriarty in the waning seconds of the third episode is a decided relief.

But let’s focus on the positive, starting with the acting of Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman.  While I still consider Cumberbatch to be the third best Holmes ever (Jeremy Brett is numero uno, followed by Basil Rathbone) Cumberbatch and Freeman are the best pair to inhabit the Doyle characters.  They are, to steal a line from The Simpsons, the original Odd Couple: Holmes is dynamic, flamboyant, a force of nature, while Watson is quiet, unassuming, and possesses an unending supply of British reserve.  Watson knows Holmes so well, yet is endlessly surprised by him.  This process of discovery is wonderfully portrayed by Freeman in the facial reactions he gives to Holmes.

The third season continues to flesh out the supporting players while adding one major new one.  Lestrade (Holmes can never remember his first name, a tip of the cap to the Doyle Canon which never supplied him with one) is still defending Holmes, still there when he calls for help even if it turns out he needs assistance with his Best Man speech at Watson’s wedding.  Molly Hooper, the morgue attendant at St. Bart’s Hospital, is still horribly in love with Holmes even after being given greater access to the object of her affections and thus a chance to see what a jerk he is.  Anderson, Holmes biggest detractor on the police force, is now the leader of a Holmes fan group.  Holmes’ brother Mycroft (played by series co-creator Mark Gatiss, who gave himself a great part) is still as supercilious and contemptuous as ever.

The addition is Mary Morstan Watson (Amanda Abbington), the woman Watson proposes to just as Holmes comes out of hiding after being thought dead for two years, and whom he marries is episode two.  Creators Gatiss and Steven Moffatt do a great job of inserting her into the delicate chemistry of Holmes and Watson; she’s not an impediment to their further adventures, she’s a catalyst.  Holmes immediately deduces there is something “off” about her (when he first reads her the word “Liar” is prominent among his deductions), but he allows Watson’s feelings to cloud his judgment.  It’s just possible she “gets” Holmes even better than Watson does (“I’m not John,” she says to Holmes at one point, “I can tell when you’re fibbing.”).

The biggest weakness of season three is that it doesn’t quite measure up to the expectations that have been established.  Unfair, but true.  It is probably impossible for the creators to ever match A Scandal in Belgravia, which had a wonderfully twisty plot that somehow all pulled together, snappy dialog (Watson: “I was a soldier, I killed people!” Holmes: “You were a doctor.”  Watson: “I had bad days!”) and the heady infusion of Lara Pulver as Irene Adler, aka “The Woman.”  Episode one of season three, The Empty Hearse, was cleverly set up but ultimately its “blow up Parliament on Guy Fawkes Day” plot came across as a mild rip-off of (or homage to) V For Vendetta.  Probably the best episode of season three was the middle one, The Sign of Three, where Holmes solves one attempted murder and thwarts another during his Best Man speech at Watson’s wedding.  Actually, the eight year old ring bearer in fact solves the crimes, which has to be a little embarrassing for Holmes.  The third episode, His Last Vow, featured a villain whose modus operandi made little sense; he was a blackmailer who apparently memorized whatever dirty information he got his hands on and then destroyed the supporting documents.  His entire ability to blackmail people was based on a bluff; all it would take is one person to sue him and his game would be up.

His Last Vow also demonstrates the increasing tendency of the stories to autocorrect Holmes’ erroneous deductions.  Early on Holmes is shot and he deduces that his life depends on whether he falls backwards or forwards.  Let’s skip over the utter implausibility of that and skip ahead to where Holmes states that the shooter aimed carefully and in fact did not want him dead.  So the shooter knew that Holmes would choose the correct way to fall?  That an ambulance would arrive in the usual 8 minutes and not be delayed long enough to allow Holmes to bleed to death?  That it is possible to shoot someone in the abdomen and know EXACTLY how long it will take them to bleed to death?  Holmes was either wrong when he decided that falling backwards was the only way to survive, or wrong when he decided the shooter didn’t want to kill him.  Either way, he is fallible.


Of course these complaints are dwarfed by the cleverness of the plots, the subtlety of the acting and the visual flair of the direction.  His Last Vow ended with a cliffhanger almost as impossible as the one that ended season two, with an apparently alive Moriarty declaring he was back and asking, “Miss me?”  After watching all three episodes of season three of Sherlock, I have to say yes, we did.  Season three started out with the creators of Sherlock resurrecting Holmes; let’s see if they can bring his arch nemesis back to life as well.  The problem is that it might take another two years.